Thursday, April 23, 2026

Meritless ERISA Claims, the Cunningham v. Cornell Burden-Shift and Judicial, Legislative, and Administrative Pushback

 


Meritless ERISA Claims, the Cunningham v. Cornell Burden-Shift and Judicial, Legislative, and Administrative Pushback

By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.

April 23, 2026

Article at 52 Journal of Pension Planning & Compliance 1 (Summer 2026) :
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_6JUGOJEpYQBpwXdjnVqvVgZnRQjerZI/

See Addendum below

The Supreme Court's 2025 decision in Cunningham v. Cornell University lowered the initial hurdles of ERISA litigation. These lawsuits typically take the form of excessive fee class actions. Plaintiff firms use template complaints (often with investigative information shared by the DOL) to allege that fiduciaries (i) failed to monitor recordkeeping fees, (ii) retained underperforming funds, or (iii) used expensive retail share classes instead of institutional ones. Cunningham v. Cornell University shifted the burden of proving exemptions for routine service contracts to plan sponsors. This made it easier for plaintiffs to survive early motions to dismiss.

However, 2026 has brought strong pushback against meritless ERISA claims and the lowered pleading standard. It's clear that courts and lawmakers are looking for ways to stop baseless claims. This article explores (i) the practical consequences of the Cunningham burden-shift, (ii) recent judicial efforts to filter meritless claims using standing and fee-shifting to plaintiff attorneys for frivolous claims, (iii) new legislative attempts to restore the burden of proof to plaintiffs, and (iv) a 2026 change in DOL Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) enforcement policy and prohibition of EBSA using secret common interest agreements with the plaintiff bar.

ERISA § 408 Exemptions as Affirmative Defenses

In Cunningham v. Cornell University, 604 U.S. 693 (Apr. 17, 2025), the Supreme Court considered a challenge to recordkeeping and administrative fee arrangements in Cornell University’s defined contribution retirement plans. Participants alleged that the plans paid excessive compensation to recordkeepers and other service providers and that plan fiduciaries failed to prudently monitor those arrangements, thereby permitting the payment of allegedly unreasonable compensation for necessary services in alleged breach of their duties of loyalty and prudence under ERISA § 404(a), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a). In addition to these fiduciary-duty claims, the plaintiffs alleged that the same fee payments constituted prohibited transactions under ERISA § 406(a)(1)(C), 29 U.S.C. § 1106(a)(1)(C), on the theory that the payments were made to service providers that were “parties in interest” to the plans. The district court and the Second Circuit rejected the prohibited transaction claim, reasoning that plaintiffs were required at the pleading stage to allege facts showing that the statutory prohibited-transaction exemption for reasonable compensation for necessary services under ERISA § 408(b)(2)(A) did not apply. The Supreme Court reversed, holding that a plaintiff states a prohibited-transaction claim under § 406(a)(1)(C) by plausibly alleging the existence of a transaction between a plan and a party in interest, and that the applicability of a § 408 exemption is an affirmative defense that must be pleaded and proved by defendants rather than negated by plaintiffs in the complaint.

Practical Consequences for Routine Service Arrangements

Because recordkeepers and similar service providers are, by definition, parties in interest under ERISA § 3(14), 29 U.S.C. § 1002(14), Cunningham renders routine service arrangements prima facie prohibited transactions at the pleading stage, subject only to later proof of an applicable exemption. Taken to its logical conclusion, the Court’s reasoning means that most routine contracts between a plan and a service provider constitute a prohibited transaction under ERISA § 406(a)(1)(C) for pleading purposes unless and until the fiduciary affirmatively establishes the applicability of a § 408 exemption. Absent that exemption, ordinary plan relationships, including recordkeeping, trustee, custodial, investment advisory, and actuarial arrangements, would be presumptively unlawful at the pleading stage, notwithstanding their ubiquity and arm’s-length nature.

Although the Court acknowledged concerns that its interpretation could expose ordinary plan arrangements to costly "fishing expeditions," it emphasized that district courts retain procedural tools to screen weak claims, including Article III standing requirements, Rule 7(a) orders, limits on discovery, Rule 11 sanctions, and fee-shifting under ERISA § 502(g)(1). In practice, however, these tools typically operate only after litigation has commenced and often after substantial defense costs have already been incurred.

Against that backdrop, in light of Cunningham, plan sponsors and fiduciaries should assume that ordinary service contracts are more likely to be challenged even in the absence of any specific wrongdoing, and should be prepared to explain, on paper and in plain terms, why each service provider was selected, how fees were reviewed, and why the arrangement makes sense for the plan.

Criticism of Cunningham as Expanding Prohibited-Transaction Litigation Beyond Its Intended Scope

Although the Supreme Court described Cunningham as a straightforward application of ERISA’s statutory structure, many commentators have questioned whether the decision aligns with economic reality and the historical purpose of ERISA’s prohibited-transaction rules and fiduciary-duty framework. By allowing prohibited-transaction claims to proceed without any allegation that compensation was excessive, unreasonable, or the result of a flawed fiduciary process, Cunningham permits plaintiffs to challenge routine, arm’s-length service arrangements that have traditionally been viewed as permissible so long as compensation is reasonable and services are necessary.

From a litigation standpoint, Cunningham makes it easier for plaintiffs to add prohibited-transaction claims to otherwise weak excessive-fee complaints in order to avoid the more demanding pleading standards that apply to ERISA § 404 prudence claims. Plaintiffs use the prohibited transaction rules as a backdoor to revive excessive fee claims when they lack direct evidence of actual fiduciary imprudence or unreasonable market rates. Because nearly all service providers qualify as parties in interest, plaintiffs generally need only allege the existence of a service relationship to survive a motion to dismiss under § 406. This shifts early litigation away from whether fees were excessive or fiduciary decision-making was imprudent and instead places immediate pressure on plan sponsors to defend ordinary plan operations. As a result, ERISA’s prohibited-transaction provisions—originally intended to prevent self-dealing and other prohibited transactions—risk being used primarily as a procedural tool to increase settlement leverage in cases where no concrete fiduciary misconduct or participant harm has been plausibly alleged.

Post-Cunningham Reduction in Successful Motions to Dismiss in ERISA Fee Cases

Since the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision in Cunningham, motions to dismiss ERISA fee cases, particularly prohibited-transaction claims under ERISA § 406, have been granted less frequently. Courts are increasingly allowing cases to proceed based solely on allegations that a plan paid fees to a service provider that qualifies as a party in interest. As a result, lawsuits that likely would have been dismissed before Cunningham are now advancing into costly discovery, including cases involving mid-sized plans that historically were not frequent litigation targets.

Judicial Pushback

Rule 7(a) Orders. In response to Cunningham, more courts are utilizing Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 7(a) to require plaintiffs to file a reply to an answer regarding reasonableness and exemptions before allowing discovery to proceed, as the Supreme Court in Cunningham suggested. For example, in Dalton v. Freeman, No. 2:22-cv-00847, 2025 WL 3771345 (E.D. Cal. Dec. 31, 2025), a California federal court ordered a Rule 7(a) reply to compel plaintiffs to address ERISA exemptions with "specific, nonconclusory factual allegations" before discovery could begin. Although the plaintiffs had survived a motion to dismiss by alleging a "prohibited transaction" under the Cunningham standard, the court used Rule 7(a) to address the "procedural issue" that otherwise allows "meritless" cases to reach discovery.

Article III Standing. A recent 2026 ruling highlights how courts are using Article III standing as a "constitutional gatekeeper" to dismiss prohibited transaction claims that might otherwise satisfy statutory pleading requirements. In Peeler v. Bayada Home Health Care, Inc., No. 1:24-cv-00231-MR, 2026 WL 208630 (W.D.N.C. Jan. 27, 2026), a North Carolina federal court dismissed an ERISA class action for lack of Article III standing, holding that a "bare allegation" of a relationship with a party in interest is insufficient without specific allegations of a concrete injury. The court held that despite recent Supreme Court guidance lowering the statutory pleading bar for prohibited transactions, plaintiffs must still identify a non-speculative financial loss actually affecting their individual accounts to satisfy constitutional requirements. Ultimately, the court found the plaintiffs' allegations were too speculative because they failed to show that their own account balances declined or that the recordkeeping and advisory services provided weren't worth what the plan paid. The court dismissed the claims without prejudice, reinforcing that statutory violations alone do not confer standing.

Fee-Shifting and Attorney Accountability. Beyond procedural rules, courts are exploring fee-shifting to deter meritless litigation. In November 2025, a U.S. district judge granted summary judgment to the defendants in Whipple v. Southeastern Freight Lines, Inc., No. 3:23-cv-04583-SAL (D.S.C. Nov. 25, 2025), dismissing a class action that alleged the company paid $3.5 million in excessive 401(k) recordkeeping fees. The ruling for the employer hinged on the court's Daubert exclusion of the plaintiffs' sole expert witness, which prevented them from establishing loss causation under ERISA. Following this dismissal, the defendants filed a motion in early 2026 under ERISA § 502(g)(1) to shift over $1 million in defense costs specifically to the plaintiffs' law firm (but not to the named participants). In an unusual but growing trend, the defense cited Cunningham guidance to argue that the firm itself bear these costs to deter "baseless" class actions that exploit lower pleading standards to force expensive discovery.

Legislative Developments

Congress has recently focused on the practical consequences of recent ERISA litigation trends. On December 2, 2025, the House Education and Workforce Subcommittee held a hearing entitled “Pension Predators: Stopping Class Action Abuse Against Workers’ Retirement,” which examined whether developments such as Cunningham have contributed to an increase in ERISA class actions driven more by procedural leverage than by demonstrable fiduciary misconduct. Witnesses and members of Congress expressed concern that lower pleading thresholds may impose substantial litigation costs on plans and ultimately reduce retirement benefits borne by participants.

On March 17, 2026, the House Education and Workforce Committee passed the ERISA Litigation Reform Act (H.R. 6084) by a vote of 19-13. This bill aims to (i) shift the burden of proof back to plaintiffs, requiring them to plausibly allege that a transaction isn't exempt under Section 408 at the pleading stage, (ii) require "meaningful benchmarks" for performance claims, (iii) mandate an automatic stay of discovery while a motion to dismiss is pending, and (iv) require plaintiffs to prove that service provider fees were neither reasonable nor necessary. Proponents argue this restores the "innocent until proven guilty" principle for plan fiduciaries.

DOL New Enforcement Guidance and Restrictions of DOL Information Sharing with Plaintiff Bar

Recent congressional hearings exposed a troubling alliance between the DOL and plaintiff attorneys. On July 22, 2025, the House Committee on Education and the Workforce investigated the DOL EBSA's use of secret common interest agreements. It was recently discovered and reported at the hearing that the EBSA uses these of secret common interest agreements with plaintiff attorneys to spoon-feed confidential investigative data to those law firms. This practice gives plaintiff attorneys unfair leverage in the case. Lawmakers heavily criticized this practice, with some calling it a blatant abuse of the law. See https://tinyurl.com/412636. In response, the DOL Inspector General launched an official audit into the information sharing by EBSA and plaintiff attorneys. A bill was also introduced in Congress, the Balance the Scales Act (H.R. 2958), to force the agency to disclose all future common interest agreements.

To address this controversy and other issues, the DOL issued Field Assistance Bulletin 2026-01 on April 14, 2026, which significantly shifts the EBSA 2026 enforcement priorities. It outlines that the DOL will shift its focus to (i) egregious conduct and loyalty breaches, (ii) avoid regulation by enforcement, (iii) require senior leadership review for critical initiatives, and (iv) ensure timely investigations. Also, the bulletin specifically prohibits agency staff from coordinating enforcement activities with plaintiff attorneys pursuing private actions. The bulletin also sets strict investigation deadlines, with routine investigations required to close within 18 months, and complex cases required to close within 30 months.

Evolving Theories: Pleading Standards and Loss Causation

Supreme Court Seeks Solicitor General Input. Following Cunningham, the Supreme Court invited the Solicitor General to express the views of the United States on whether to grant certiorari in two ERISA class actions highlighting significant circuit splits. On December 9, 2025, the Solicitor General urged the Court to grant certiorari in Parker-Hannifin Corp. v. Johnson and Pizarro v. Home Depot, Inc. (both cited below) and supported plan sponsor and fiduciary defendants on the merits. This reflected a shift toward a more pragmatic interpretation by endorsing meaningful-benchmark pleading standards and rejecting expansive burden-shifting theories of loss causation.

Pleading Standards in Parker-Hannifin and Intel Corp. In Parker-Hannifin Corp. v. Johnson, 122 F.4th 205 (6th Cir. 2024), the Sixth Circuit allowed an investment-performance challenge to proceed without requiring the plaintiff to plausibly allege a "meaningful benchmark," which allows the court to determine whether plaintiffs have alleged plausible claims to survive a motion to dismiss, an approach taken by some circuits, while other circuits merely require a showing of meaningful comparability. While the Solicitor General urged the Court to hear the case and reverse the Sixth Circuit's lenient standard, the Supreme Court is still considering whether to grant certiorari as of March 2026. However, the Court has already agreed to resolve this specific "meaningful benchmark" split in a related case, Anderson v. Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee, the Court granted certiorari in January 2026.

Loss Causation in Pizarro v. Home Depot, Inc. In Pizarro v. Home Depot, Inc., 111 F.4th 1165 (11th Cir. 2024), the Eleventh Circuit held that ERISA plaintiffs retain the burden of proving loss causation even after establishing a breach of fiduciary duty and a loss, rejecting a burden-shifting framework adopted by several other circuits. The Solicitor General supported this view, arguing that the burden should remain with the plaintiffs. Following the filing of the Solicitor General's brief, the plaintiffs chose to abandon their appeal, and the Supreme Court therefore dismissed the petition on January 8, 2026.

Meaningful Benchmarks in Anderson v. Intel. In Anderson v. Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee, 137 F.4th 1015 (9th Cir. 2025), participants in its retirement plans alleged that trustees imprudently invested in risky hedge funds and private equity that yielded lower returns than traditional investments. The Ninth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of the participants' claims, ruling that they failed to plausibly allege a breach of fiduciary duty under ERISA as the complaint did not provide  meaningful benchmarks with similar investment aims, risks, and objectives.  The Supreme Court granted review on January 16, 2026, to resolve whether plaintiffs challenging investment underperformance must identify a "meaningful benchmark" at the pleading stage to satisfy ERISA's duty of prudence.  

Looking Ahead

The current landscape of ERISA litigation is highly volatile. Cunningham gave plaintiffs significant procedural leverage, but the recent judicial, legislative, and administrative pushback shows that the pendulum may be swinging back. DOL Field Assistance Bulletin 2026-01 strengthens this defense trend. Plan sponsors gain protection from endless audits through new 18-month and 30-month investigation deadlines for the EBSA.ESBA Furthermore, the ban on secret common interest agreements between the EBSA and the plaintiff bar cuts off a major source of free discovery. Plan sponsors should not wait for the law to settle. They must proactively document their fiduciary processes and clearly explain why they chose specific service providers and how they negotiated fees. Moving forward, the industry is closely watching the Supreme Court's upcoming decision in Anderson v. Intel Corp. and the progress of the ERISA Litigation Reform Act and other legislative developments. These upcoming developments will determine if the Cunningham burden-shift continues to be an issue for plan sponsors.

11-17-26 Addendum

Update — November 17, 2026: Further Developments in ERISA Litigation

Since this article was posted on April 23, 2026, several developments have reinforced the growing judicial and legislative scrutiny of meritless ERISA class actions.

Supreme Court Review of ERISA Pleading Standards. On October 6, 2026, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Anderson v. Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee, No. 25-498, involving the requirement that plaintiffs challenging investment underperformance identify a meaningful benchmark. The Ninth Circuit had dismissed the claims because plaintiffs failed to identify sufficiently comparable investments. During oral argument, several Justices appeared receptive to requiring meaningful comparisons, although the appropriate degree of comparability remains disputed. A decision is expected during the Court's 2026–2027 Term. Unlike Cunningham v. Cornell University, which addressed prohibited transactions under ERISA § 406, Anderson concerns the pleading requirements for fiduciary imprudence under § 404. See Supreme Court docket.

Judicial Safeguards Against Weak Claims. Courts have continued exploring the procedural protections identified in Cunningham. In Dalton v. Freeman, No. 2:22-cv-00847, 2025 WL 3771345 (E.D. Cal. Dec. 31, 2025), the court required plaintiffs to respond under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 7(a)(7) to defendants' prohibited-transaction exemption defense. However, the case subsequently proceeded toward discovery, illustrating the limitations of this safeguard. In Peeler v. Bayada Home Health Care, Inc., No. 1:24-cv-00231-MR, 2026 WL 208630 (W.D.N.C. Jan. 27, 2026), the court dismissed claims for lack of Article III standing, emphasizing that Cunningham did not eliminate the requirement of concrete injury.

Legislative Developments. The ERISA Litigation Reform Act (H.R. 6084), which the House Education and Workforce Committee ordered reported on March 17, 2026, remains pending. The legislation would impose more demanding pleading requirements, including provisions addressing statutory exemptions and meaningful investment benchmarks, and would restrict discovery while certain dismissal motions are pending. No legislation reversing Cunningham has been enacted.

DOL Enforcement and Information Sharing. The DOL's April 14, 2026 Field Assistance Bulletin 2026-01 remains an important change in enforcement policy. It emphasizes serious violations, discourages regulation through enforcement, establishes 18-month and 30-month administrative investigation targets subject to exceptions, and restricts coordination with private plaintiffs' attorneys. These policies do not alter the rights of private litigants or create enforceable deadlines for investigations. See DOL Field Assistance Bulletin 2026-01.

Practical Significance. Although Cunningham continues to expose routine service-provider arrangements to prohibited-transaction litigation, courts and policymakers are considering ways to prevent weak claims from imposing disproportionate litigation costs. The forthcoming Anderson decision may provide important additional guidance concerning speculative investment-performance claims. Meanwhile, plan fiduciaries should continue documenting the reasonableness of service-provider compensation, investment selection, and ongoing monitoring procedures.

 


Monday, March 2, 2026

ERISA Fiduciary Advice: The Regulatory Landscape for 2026

 


ERISA Fiduciary Advice: The Regulatory Landscape for 2026

By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
201.357.0577

March, 2026

Recent court decisions have effectively nullified the Department of Labor’s 2024 Retirement Security Rule. Two federal courts stayed the rule, finding that the DOL likely exceeded its authority, and in November 2025 the DOL withdrew its appeals. In March 2026, the DOL published a notice recognizing the judicial vacatur of the 2024 Retirement Security Rule. As a result, fiduciary status for investment advice continues to be governed by the reinstated 1975 five-part test and the original version of PTE 2020-02, alongside the SEC’s Regulation Best Interest.

The Department of Labor’s effort to revise the fiduciary investment-advice standard has become a recurring subject of rulemaking and litigation. Major definitional changes were proposed under successive presidential administrations. The most recent development came in March 2026, when the DOL published a notice recognizing the judicial vacatur of the 2024 Retirement Security Rule. As a result, the 2024 rule and its accompanying amendments to the prohibited-transaction exemptions never took effect. ERISA fiduciary advice therefore continues to be governed by the 1975 five-part test and the reinstated original PTE 2020-02.

I. The 1975 Rule and the 2016 Fiduciary Rule

ERISA’s investment-advice fiduciary definition originates in 1975, when the Ford Administration adopted a regulation providing that a person is a fiduciary only if all elements of a five-part test are satisfied. 40 Fed. Reg. 50842 (Oct. 31, 1975); DOL Reg. § 2510.3-21(c). The 1975 five-part test dictates that a person providing investment advice for a fee is a fiduciary with respect to a plan’s or IRA’s assets only if the advice (i) concerns the value or sale of investment property, (ii) is given on a regular basis, (iii) is provided under a mutual understanding that it will serve as (iv) a primary basis for the retirement investment decision, and (v) is individualized to the investor.

The 2016 Fiduciary Rule replaced the 1975 rule. The 2016 rule imposed fiduciary status when a person made an investment recommendation regarding retirement plan or IRA assets, including one-time advice such as rollovers, under circumstances where the adviser either (i) acknowledged acting as an ERISA fiduciary or (ii) provided advice under an agreement that the advice was based on the recipient’s particular needs. This expansion brought brokers, insurance agents, and others, who were previously held only to a lower suitability standard, under ERISA’s stringent duties of care and loyalty, thereby protecting retirement savers from conflicted advice. To allow financial institutions to continue receiving common forms of compensation, such as commissions, the rule introduced new prohibited-transaction class exemptions, most notably the Best Interest Contract Exemption (BICE), which mandated adherence to Impartial Conduct Standards and required a written contract acknowledging fiduciary status. 81 Fed. Reg. 21002 (Apr. 8, 2016).

However, in 2018, the Fifth Circuit vacated the 2016 Fiduciary Rule in full, holding that the DOL exceeded its statutory authority. Chamber of Commerce v. U.S. DOL, 885 F.3d 360 (5th Cir. 2018).

During the first Trump Administration, the DOL issued 2020 technical amendments to DOL Reg. § 2510.3-21, removing the vacated 2016 Fiduciary Rule from the regulations and reinstating the 1975 test. See 85 Fed. Reg. 40589 (July 7, 2020).

At the same time, the DOL adopted PTE 2020-02, Improving Investment Advice for Workers & Retirees, 85 Fed. Reg. 82798 (Dec. 18, 2020). This exemption remains operative.

In 2019, the Securities and Exchange Commission adopted Regulation Best Interest (“Reg BI”), requiring broker-dealers, when making recommendations to retail customers, to act in the customer’s best interest and not place their own financial interests ahead of the investor’s. Reg BI created a federal securities-law “best interest” standard distinct from the ERISA fiduciary definition. See Regulation Best Interest, Exchange Act Release No. 34-86031, 84 Fed. Reg. 33318 (July 12, 2019). Reg BI remains in effect.

II. The 2024 Retirement Security Rule

In April 2024, under the Biden Administration, the DOL issued the 2024 Retirement Security Rule, which was intended to replace the 1975 five-part test with a modernized fiduciary definition based on adviser representations and investor expectations. Retirement Security Rule—Definition of an Investment Advice Fiduciary, 89 Fed. Reg. 32122 (Apr. 25, 2024).

Under the 2024 Retirement Security Rule’s three-element test, a financial professional would become an ERISA fiduciary if (i) an investment recommendation was made to a retirement investor, (ii) it was provided for a fee, and (iii) the adviser either affirmatively stated fiduciary status or held itself out as a trusted adviser providing individualized best-interest guidance. The rule also included amendments to PTE 2020-02 designed to standardize conduct requirements across advisory and insurance channels.

These changes were scheduled to take effect on September 23, 2024, but were stayed by litigation.

III. The 2024 Litigation, 2025 Appeal Dismissal, and 2026 Vacatur

Before the 2024 Retirement Security Rule took effect, two federal district courts stayed it. These cases were Federation of Americans for Consumer Choice, Inc. v. DOL, 742 F. Supp. 3d 677 (E.D. Tex. 2024), and American Council of Life Insurers v. DOL, Docket No. 4:24-cv-00482, 2024 WL 3572297 (N.D. Tex. 2024). Both courts concluded that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in arguing that the DOL again exceeded its statutory authority by extending fiduciary obligations to sales practices and one-time recommendations.

In November 2025, the DOL filed an unopposed motion to voluntarily dismiss its consolidated appeals. Mot. to Dismiss, Federation of Americans for Consumer Choice v. DOL, Case Nos. 24-40637 & 24-10890 (5th Cir. Nov. 2025). The Fifth Circuit granted the dismissal on November 28, 2025, leaving the district-court stays intact. The DOL then published an official Notice of Court Vacatur, 91 Fed. Reg. 18213 (Mar. 20, 2026). Because the 2024 exemption amendments were part of the same rulemaking, they also never took effect and were officially void.

IV. Where Things Stand Now and What to Expect

Following the withdrawal of the DOL appeal and the March 2026 notice of vacatur of the 2024 Retirement Security Rule, that rule is not operative. The controlling fiduciary framework remains the 1975 five-part test in DOL Reg. § 2510.3-21, which was restated in the March 2026 notice. 91 Fed. Reg. 18213 (Mar. 20, 2026).

The DOL republished the operative text of PTE 2020-02 in the March notice. It did not include the preamble sections that courts had invalidated. Nevertheless, financial institutions must continue navigating the practical overlap between ERISA fiduciary standards and the SEC’s 2019 Regulation Best Interest rule, 84 Fed. Reg. 33318 (July 12, 2019).


Addendum

Further developments in April 2026 clarified the application of the reinstated 1975 five-part test to rollover recommendations.

In its March 20, 2026 notice, the DOL not only restored the 1975 fiduciary definition but also concluded that the entire preamble to PTE 2020-02 was effectively vacated. Although federal courts had expressly invalidated only portions of that preamble, the DOL determined that the remaining interpretive guidance was too closely intertwined with the invalidated provisions to be reliable. The operative provisions of PTE 2020-02, however, remain in effect. 91 Fed. Reg. 13503, 13504–05 (Mar. 20, 2026).

A further development occurred on April 24, 2026, when the DOL and the Federation of Americans for Consumer Choice filed a joint stipulation dismissing litigation challenging the DOL's 2020 interpretation of rollover advice. The stipulation confirmed that the DOL had reinstated Advisory Opinion 2005-23A (Dec. 7, 2005), commonly known as the Deseret Letter, and would no longer rely on the broader interpretation contained in the 2020 preamble.

Under that advisory opinion, a recommendation by a person who is not otherwise a plan fiduciary to roll assets from an ERISA plan into an IRA generally does not, standing alone, constitute fiduciary investment advice with respect to the plan. The analysis remains subject to the facts and circumstances and the requirements of the 1975 five-part test.

These developments substantially narrow the circumstances in which a one-time rollover recommendation establishes fiduciary status under ERISA. They do not, however, eliminate fiduciary obligations where the five-part test is otherwise satisfied, nor do they repeal PTE 2020-02. Financial institutions relying on that exemption must continue to satisfy its applicable conditions, including its impartial conduct standards.

The DOL has also stated that it has no current plans to undertake new notice-and-comment rulemaking concerning the definition of investment advice fiduciary. For now, the reinstated 1975 five-part test, the restored 2005 rollover guidance, and the operative provisions of PTE 2020-02 provide the governing federal framework.

Wednesday, February 11, 2026

Compliance Update: The Rapidly Expanding Scope of the IRC § 162(m) Limit on Deductibility of Compensation in Excess of $1 Million

  

Compliance Update: The Rapidly Expanding Scope of the
IRC § 162(m) Limit on Deductibility of Compensation in Excess of $1 Million

By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
201.357.0577

Feb. 11, 2026

The Internal Revenue Code § 162(m) $1 Million Deduction Limit if a Publicly Held Corporation Is in the Group. Businesses can usually deduct the full amount of salaries and bonuses they pay to their employees as a necessary business expense. However, Section 162(m) of the tax code creates a massive exception for public companies. It provides that once a “covered employee” (typically a top executive) makes more than $1 million in a single year, the company can no longer deduct any pay above that $1 million threshold. This means the company must pay corporate income taxes on that “excess” pay as if it were profit, which effectively increases the cost of employing top talent. While this rule was once a simple calculation for the CEO and a few top officers, recent laws have expanded it to cover more employees and even private companies that are part of a larger business group.

Executive Summary. The federal tax landscape for executive compensation has shifted dramatically over the last few years. While the $1 million deduction limit under IRC § 162(m) was once a predictable math exercise for public companies, a number of developments have significantly widened the regulatory net: (i) the One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 (“OBBBA”) expansion pulls in private entities and non-corporate businesses that are affiliated with publicly held corporations; (ii) the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (“ARPA”) “Next Five” rules target non-officers; and (iii) the September 2024 IRS Audit Technique Guide threatens legacy contracts. Starting in 2026, many previously exempt private entities will find themselves subject to these limits for the first time. This memo outlines the critical changes your tax and HR teams must address immediately to avoid unexpected tax hits.

1. The OBBBA Expansion: Controlled Group Aggregation (Effective 2026). The One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 2025 (Pub. L. 119-21, § 70603), signed into law on July 4, 2025, represents the most significant recent change to § 162(m) since 2017. It moves the law from “Affiliated Groups” to the much broader “Controlled Group” definition found in IRC § 414(b), (c), (m), and (o). Historically, only corporate subsidiaries were usually included, but now partnerships and LLCs with 80% common control are pulled in under IRC § 162(m)(2). Also, this change means a public company’s $1 million limit must be shared across every member of that group that pays the executive. Companies can no longer isolate compensation in a private subsidiary to preserve a deduction. This expansion brings partnerships and unincorporated trades or businesses under common control into the regulatory net if they are affiliated with a public corporation, meaning a private subsidiary’s deduction may be limited even if it is not the public entity itself.

2. The Tier 2 Revolution: The Next Five (Effective 2027). Under the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021, the definition of a “covered employee” expands for tax years beginning after December 31, 2026 (i.e., 2027 for calendar-year corporations). ARPA creates a two-tiered system for tracking high earners. Specifically: (i) Tier 1 includes the CEO, CFO, and the three other highest-compensated executive officers (as determined under SEC rules), who remain “covered employees” permanently under the “once a covered employee, always a covered employee” rule; (ii) Tier 2 adds the next five highest-paid employees, who need not be officers; and (iii) unlike Tier 1, Tier 2 employees remain covered only for the years in which they rank among the top five highest-paid employees.

The January 2025 proposed amendments to Treas. Reg. § 1.162-33 (90 Fed. Reg. 4691 (Jan. 16, 2025)) provide interpretive guidance on how Tier 2 employees are identified and ranked. The proposed regulations clarify that Tier 2 employees are ranked using tax-based compensation principles (e.g., Form W-2 Box 1 wages), rather than the SEC proxy disclosure framework used for Tier 1 determinations. They also include an anti-avoidance rule under which individuals are treated as employees if they perform “substantially all” services for the corporation, even if they are technically paid by a Professional Employer Organization (PEO). In addition, multinational groups must aggregate foreign-paid compensation from Controlled Foreign Corporations (CFCs) when determining the “Next Five.” Because Tier 2 status is not permanent, a one-time compensation spike does not result in a lifetime deduction limitation for that employee.

3. IRS Audit Focus: The Death of Negative Discretion. For companies still relying on “grandfathered” contracts in effect on November 2, 2017, the margin for error has vanished. The September 2024 IRS Section 162(m) Audit Technique Guide (Publication 6014) imposes rigorous scrutiny on these legacy awards, namely: (i) it focuses on negative discretion, i.e., the committee’s power to reduce a formula-based bonus payout; (ii) the IRS now argues this power means the contract was not “binding” back in 2017 because the amount was not fixed; and (iii) any material modification, like moving up a payment date without a discount for the time value of money, will eliminate the grandfathered status and lose the deduction. One has to be extremely careful with any changes to these old deals to ensure no inadvertent modifications have occurred.

Immediate Action Items. To prepare for these shifts, we recommend the following steps: (i) map out your entire organizational structure under the § 414 controlled group rules to identify every entity now subject to proration; (ii) begin “shadow tracking” your top five non-officer earners now to prepare for the 2027 Tier 2 list; (iii) have counsel review any remaining grandfathered awards against the 2024 Audit Guide; and (iv) identify any high earners formally employed by third parties (like PEOs) who may now be subject to the limit. Early coordination among payroll, benefits, and finance teams is essential. The controlled group aggregation rules already apply for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025, and the Tier 2 rules take effect for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2026, so systems should be updated now rather than at year-end.

 

Wednesday, December 17, 2025

Mandatory Roth Catch-Up Contributions Take Effect January 1, 2026

 


Mandatory Roth Catch-Up Contributions Take Effect January 1, 2026

By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
201.357.0577

December 17, 2026

The IRS has issued important final regulations under SECURE 2.0 requiring age-50 catch-up contributions to be made on a Roth (after-tax) basis for employees whose prior-year wages exceed a specified threshold ($150,000 when first applied in 2026). Although Congress originally scheduled this change for 2024, the IRS delayed mandatory implementation until 2026 and provided additional time for plan amendments. The regulations include detailed guidance on determining which employees are subject to the Roth requirement, how payroll systems must apply it, optional coordination rules for related employers, and correction of errors. Employers offering catch-up contributions should ensure that Roth features are available and administrative procedures are updated.

I. Overview

The IRS and Treasury have issued final regulations, T.D. 10033, 90 Fed. Reg. 44527 (Sept. 16, 2025), implementing IRC §414(v)(7), which was enacted as part of the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 and fundamentally changes how age-50 catch-up contributions operate for higher-wage participants.

Although the statute originally provided that mandatory Roth catch-up contributions would apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2023, subsequent IRS transition relief postponed operational enforcement. As a result, mandatory Roth-only catch-up contributions become effective for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025, and therefore apply beginning January 1, 2026.

While the final regulations provide that full regulatory compliance is generally required beginning in 2027, plans may rely on reasonable, good-faith interpretations through the 2026 transition period. This memorandum summarizes the catch-up contribution framework as it applies under the final regulations, explains the Roth-only mandate, and outlines the applicable amendment and compliance deadlines.

II. Background: Catch-Up Contributions Under §414(v)

Under IRC §414(v), individuals who are age 50 or older (or who will attain age 50 by the end of the taxable year) may make additional catch-up contributions beyond the §401(a)(30)/§402(g) elective deferral limits. These limits have increased over time, reaching $8,000 for 2026 for §401(k) and §403(b) plans. Catch-up contributions are exempt from the ADP test, the §415(c) annual addition limits, and the top-heavy rules for the year made.

Although plans are not required to offer catch-up contributions, those that do must satisfy the universal availability requirement of Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-1(e), under which all catch-up-eligible participants must have the same effective opportunity to make them.

The SECURE 2.0 Act also introduced enhanced catch-up limits for participants ages 60–63 beginning in 2025. Those enhanced limits equal the greater of $10,000 (indexed after 2025) or 150% of the regular catch-up amount, subject to the applicable statutory calculation. SIMPLE plan catch-up limits are subject to separate increases under SECURE 2.0.

III. SECURE 2.0 Roth Catch-Up Mandate

Section 603 of SECURE 2.0 added IRC §414(v)(7), which requires that catch-up contributions for participants with prior-year FICA wages exceeding a statutory threshold be made as designated Roth contributions. For 2023–2025, the statutory threshold is $145,000; beginning in 2026, the threshold is indexed in $5,000 increments, increasing to $150,000 for determinations based on 2025 wages. The Roth mandate applies to §401(k), §403(b), and governmental §457(b) plans; SIMPLE IRAs and SEP arrangements are excluded.

Although the statutory effective date was originally set for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2023, IRS Notice 2023-62 delayed the mandatory application of §414(v)(7) for two years. As a result, participants are not required to make Roth-only catch-up contributions in 2024 or 2025. The final regulations confirm this transition relief and provide that the Roth-only mandate first becomes operationally required for taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025—meaning that 2026 is the first year in which plans must enforce Roth-only catch-up contributions.

IRS Notice 2023-62 also permits reasonable, good-faith interpretations of §414(v)(7) during the transition period. The final regulations generally become applicable beginning in 2027, unless a plan elects earlier application.

IV. Key Features of the Final Regulations and Their Effective Dates

The final regulations at Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-2 and related amendments define who is subject to the Roth catch-up requirement, how the rule applies in operation, and what correction and administrative procedures are necessary. The following provisions are particularly relevant for plan sponsors.

Who is subject to the Roth catch-up requirement. Under Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-2(a)(2), a participant is subject to the Roth-only mandate if the participant is otherwise catch-up-eligible and had FICA wages from the employer sponsoring the plan that exceeded the applicable threshold for the preceding calendar year. The test is mechanical and employer-specific. A participant whose 2025 wages exceed $150,000 must make all 2026 catch-up contributions on a Roth basis.

Optional wage aggregation rules. Under Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-2(b)(4), plans may elect, but are not required, to aggregate FICA wages across (i) employers using a common paymaster, (ii) employers in a controlled group or affiliated service group, or (iii) predecessor and successor employers in an asset transaction. If the plan does not elect aggregation, wages are tested separately for each employer, even within a single multiple-employer plan.

Scope of the Roth requirement and interaction with elective deferral limits. The Roth mandate applies only to elective deferrals that qualify as catch-up contributions under Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-1(c)(3). Higher-wage participants may still make pre-tax elective deferrals up to the §401(a)(30)/§402(g) limit. Roth treatment becomes mandatory for catch-up contributions. The final regulations clarify that earlier designated Roth contributions count toward satisfying the Roth requirement, avoiding an all-or-nothing Roth conversion.

Universal availability rules and high-wage participants. The final regulations clarify that a plan does not violate universal availability merely because it does not permit catch-up contributions for participants who exceed the wage threshold. In practice, one plan in a controlled group may offer full Roth catch-ups while another may deny catch-ups entirely to higher-wage participants, without violating Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-1(e).

Deemed Roth catch-up elections. Under Treas. Reg. §1.401(k)-1(f)(5), plans may use deemed Roth elections for participants subject to §414(v)(7), provided participants retain an effective opportunity to make alternative elections. Deemed elections must cease within a reasonable period after a participant is determined no longer to exceed the wage threshold or an amended Form W-2 establishes that the participant is not subject to the requirement.

Plans lacking a Roth contribution feature. Under Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-2(b)(2), if a plan does not include a designated Roth contribution program under §402A(b), a participant subject to the Roth requirement has a maximum catch-up limit of zero. Sponsors wishing to preserve catch-up contributions for higher-wage employees must therefore add a Roth feature.

Correction mechanisms. Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-2(c) establishes correction rules for operational failures, including (i) correction through Form W-2 reporting before issuance or (ii) in-plan Roth rollovers reported on Form 1099-R. Plans using these correction methods must include an appropriate deemed Roth catch-up election in their plan documents. Relief applies to certain de minimis failures not exceeding $250 and failures resulting from late amended Forms W-2.

V. Effective Dates and Required Amendments

The interaction of statutory language, IRS transition relief, and regulatory applicability produces the following compliance timeline.

The Roth-only requirement under §414(v)(7) does not apply in 2024 or 2025 because of the administrative transition relief in IRS Notice 2023-62. The first year in which plans must require Roth-only catch-up contributions is 2026, based on 2025 FICA wages.

The final regulations generally apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2026. Thus, 2027 is the first year in which plans must comply with the detailed regulatory framework, unless the plan elects earlier application under Treas. Reg. §1.414(v)-2(e)(2)(iv). Certain governmental and collectively bargained plans have later applicability dates.

At the time of publication, the applicable SECURE 2.0 amendment guidance generally contemplated amendments by the end of the 2027 plan year for nongovernmental plans, with later deadlines for certain governmental plans. Subsequent IRS guidance concerning required amendments is discussed in the November 2026 addendum below.

Accordingly, plan sponsors may operate under a reasonable, good-faith interpretation of §414(v)(7) through 2026, even if the final regulatory language has not yet been added to the plan, provided that 2026 operations correctly enforce Roth-only treatment for participants exceeding the wage threshold.

VI. Action Steps for Plan Sponsors

Plan sponsors should ensure that preparations for the 2026 Roth-only operational mandate are completed. Employers should (i) adopt a Roth contribution feature if catch-up contributions are to remain available to higher-wage participants beginning in 2026; (ii) coordinate with payroll providers to ensure accurate prior-year FICA wage determinations; (iii) update participant communications and election materials; (iv) evaluate controlled group practices, since different plans may permissibly adopt different approaches for higher-wage participants; (v) implement operational procedures for deemed Roth elections and correction methods during the transition period; and (vi) monitor applicable plan amendment deadlines.

VII. Conclusion

The September 2025 final regulations represent one of the most significant changes to catch-up contribution administration in more than a decade. Plan sponsors should be operating Roth-only catch-up contributions beginning in 2026 and should ensure that Roth features, deemed election procedures, and correction mechanisms are in place before the 2027 regulatory applicability date. Continued coordination with payroll providers and recordkeepers will be essential to ensure proper administration and ongoing compliance.

 

Addendum: 11-17-26 – 2027 Limits and Plan Amendment Deadlines

2027 Roth catch-up limits. IRS Notice 2026-66 increases the mandatory Roth catch-up wage threshold to $155,000 for 2027, based on 2026 FICA wages. The regular age-50 catch-up limit increases to $8,500, while the enhanced catch-up limit for ages 60–63 increases to $11,750. With the regular elective deferral limit increasing to $25,500, the maximum combined deferrals are $34,000 and $37,250, respectively.

Extended amendment deadline. In September 2026, the IRS clarified in Employee Plans News, “Clarifying Deadlines for SECURE and SECURE 2.0 Required and Discretionary Plan Amendments,” that required amendments implementing SECURE 2.0 §603 generally will not be due until December 31, 2029, rather than the previously anticipated 2027 deadline, under the remedial amendment framework of Rev. Proc. 2022-40. Certain discretionary SECURE 2.0 amendments remain subject to earlier deadlines, generally December 31, 2026, under IRS Notice 2024-2. The extension does not affect operational compliance: the Roth catch-up mandate has applied since January 1, 2026, and the detailed final regulations generally become applicable in 2027. 

 

 

Friday, November 7, 2025

Forfeitures in Qualified Plans: (i) Proposed Regulations; and (ii) Fiduciary Class Action Suits

 


Forfeitures in Qualified Plans: (i) Proposed Regulations; and (ii) Fiduciary Class Action Suits

By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.

November 7, 2025

I. Part 1 – 2023 Proposed Regulations Regarding Forfeitures

2023 Proposed Regulations Regarding Forfeitures. The IRS has long permitted using forfeitures of defined contribution plans to pay plan expenses or reduce future contributions (and not just to reduce plan expenses), as long as this is documented in the plan. See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 71-313; Rev. Proc. 2016-51 § 6.02(4)(c); IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010). In February 2023, the IRS issued proposed regulations with specific rules for forfeitures of defined benefit plans and for forfeitures of defined contribution plans. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7, 88 Fed. Reg. 12282 (Feb. 27, 2023). These regulations are proposed to apply for plan years beginning on or after January 1,  2024, once finalized, and they have not yet been finalized. But Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(d) and the Preamble provide that taxpayers may rely on these proposed regulations for periods preceding the effective date of the regulations.

Three Options For Forfeitures In Defined Contributions Plans. The 2023 proposed regulations provide that for forfeitures under a qualified defined contribution plan, the plan must provide that forfeitures will be used for one or more of the following purposes: (i) to pay plan administrative expenses; (ii) to reduce employer contributions under the plan; or (iii) to increase benefits in other participants’ accounts (in a nondiscriminatory fashion) in accordance with plan terms. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(b)(1).

12-Month Deadline to Allocate Forfeitures in Defined Contribution Plans. The 2023 proposed regulations also provide that for defined contribution plans, the forfeitures must be used no later than 12 months following the close of the plan year in which the forfeitures were incurred under the plan, and this rule must be stated in the plan. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(b)(2).[1] As stated in the Preamble, this deadline is intended to simplify administration by providing a single deadline for the use of forfeitures that applies for all types of defined contribution plans and to alleviate administrative burdens that may arise in using or allocating forfeitures if forfeitures are incurred late in a plan year. Forfeitures incurred during any plan year that begins before January 1, 2024, will be treated as having been incurred in the first plan year that begins on or after January 1, 2024. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(c). 

The Preamble gives an example that if there are $25,000 of forfeitures in a plan year, and the plan incurs only $10,000 in plan administrative expenses before the end of the 12-month period following the end of that plan year, there will be $15,000 of forfeitures that remain unused after the deadline established in these proposed regulations, and the plan would incur an operational qualification failure because forfeitures remain unused at the end of the 12-month period following the end of that plan year.

Forfeitures in Defined Benefit Plans may not be Used to Increase Benefits to any Employees under the Plan but are Instead Utilized as an Actuarial Gain That Reduces Future Required Employer Contributions. Code §401(a)(8) provides that a defined benefit plan will not be qualified unless the plan provides that forfeitures must not be applied to increase the benefits any employee would otherwise receive under the plan. The 2023 proposed regulations provide that for forfeitures in defined benefit plans the plan must provide that forfeitures may not be applied to increase the benefits any employee would otherwise receive under the plan, unless there is a plan termination or freeze of contributions the plan. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(a). This rule is also in the original 1963 Treas. Reg. §1.401-7. (The proposed regulations do not contemplate using forfeitures in defined benefit plans to offset plan expenses, because actuarial assumptions regarding future contributions already account for the forfeitures.)

The Proposed 2023 Regulations Provide that Forfeitures in Defined Benefit Plans may be Used to Reduce Future Contributions. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(a). However, in contrast to the original 1963 regulations, which stated that defined contribution plan forfeitures must be used as soon as possible to reduce the employer’s contributions under the plan, the proposed 2023 regulations have removed this requirement because reasonable actuarial assumptions under the Internal Revenue Code already account for the forfeitures as an actuarial gain that reduces future required employer contributions. Instead, the proposed regulations provide that for defined benefit plans, the effect of forfeitures may be anticipated in determining the costs under the reasonable actuarial assumptions set forth in IRC §§430(h)(1), 431(c)(3) 433(c)(3). Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(a). As noted above, taxpayers may rely on these proposed regulations for periods preceding the effective date of the regulations.

 

II. Part 2. Recent Wave of Litigation re Use of Plan Forfeitures to Reduce Employer Contributions Rather than to Reduce Participant Administrative Expenses

Forfeiture Class Action Litigation. Class action litigation related to retirement plan forfeitures has surged dramatically since late 2023 and continued through 2025. The primary trend involves lawsuits challenging the common practice of using forfeited, unvested employer contributions to offset future employer contributions to the retirement plans (for example the employer match in 401(k) plans), rather than using them to cover plan expenses that otherwise may be charged to participants' accounts. 

Dozens of Class Action Lawsuits. Close to 80 class action lawsuits have been filed since September 2023 in the U.S. regarding use of forfeitures of retirement plans to reduce future contributions rather than to reduce administrative claims that may be charged to participants, including cases against HP Inc., Intuit, JPMorgan Chase and Qualcomm (all discussed below). Plaintiffs argue that the decision on how to use forfeitures, when a plan document provides discretion, is a "fiduciary act" under ERISA. They contend that fiduciaries breach their duty of loyalty and prudence by choosing to benefit the employer (by reducing employer contributions) over plan participants (by reducing participant-borne administrative fees).

Some District Courts Have Summarily Dismissed the Claims and Others Have Allowed Claims to Proceed to Litigation. District court rulings in forfeiture class actions have been inconsistent, with some cases dismissed in favor of plan sponsors. See, e.g., Hutchins v. HP Inc., 767 F. Supp. 3d 912 (N.D. Cal. 2025) (in putative class action by former employee alleging breach of fiduciary duties when plan sponsor decided to use 401(k) plan forfeitures to reduce employer contributions rather than to pay administrative costs, the court found that the employer's use of forfeitures to reduce future employer contributions did not breach fiduciary duties, as it complied with the plan document and ERISA requirements; case is being appealed by the plaintiffs in the Ninth Circuit, and the DOL has filed an amicus brief in favor of HP Inc.); Sievert v. Knight-Swift Transportation, 780 F. Supp. 3d 870 (D. Ariz. 2025) (the court dismissed the suit, finding that the plan document permitted the use of forfeitures to reduce future employer contributions; the decision was further supported by longstanding IRS regulations allowing such practices in defined contribution plans); Wright v. JPMorgan Chase & Co et al., 2025 WL 3798391 (C.D. Cal. June 13, 2025) (dismissed with prejudice so that it cannot be refiled in the district; court ruled that the 401(k) fiduciaries properly followed the plan's explicit terms, which granted discretion to use forfeitures to offset employer contributions).

Others forfeiture class action district court cases have allowed the cases to proceed. Buescher v. North American Lighting, 2:24-cv-02076, 2025 WL 1927503 (C.D. Ill. June 30, 2025) (the court allowed the case to proceed, finding that the plaintiff had sufficiently alleged that the plan committee used an imprudent process in allocating forfeitures, which could support a breach of fiduciary duty claim); Perez-Cruet v. Qualcomm, 23-cv-1890-BEN, 2024 WL 2702207 (S.D. Cal. May 24, 2024) (the court allowed the case to proceed, finding that the use of forfeitures to reduce future employer contributions instead of offsetting plan expenses could have eliminated participant fees, which is partially passed onto employees); Rodriguez v. Intuit, Inc., 744 F. Supp. 3d 935 (N.D. Cal. 2024) (motion to dismiss largely denied; one of the first high-profile companies hit with this type of lawsuit; district court initially denied most of its motion to dismiss in 2024, giving the plaintiffs an early win and validating the legal theory; case ultimately settled in 2025).

The outcomes often hinge on the specific language of the plan documents.

Some Dismissed District Court Cases Are Being Appealed to the Federal Courts of Appeal. Several dismissed forfeiture cases are currently on appeal in the Ninth Circuit (Hutchins v. HP Inc., discussed above), Third Circuit (Cain v. Siemens Corp. and Barragan v. Honeywell Int'l), Eighth Circuit (Matula v. Wells Fargo) and Eleventh Circuit (Cano v. Home Depot, Inc.). These appellate decisions in late 2025 and 2026 will likely bring greater clarity to the legal landscape.

DOL Amicus Brief in Support of Plan Sponsors in Hutchins v. HP Inc. The DOL, in a July 9, 2025 amicus brief No. 25-826 for Hutchins v. HP Inc., before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, on appeal from dismissal by district court in 767 F. Supp. 3d 912 (N.D. Cal. 2025), supported the plan sponsor, stating that while the allocation of expenses is a fiduciary decision, the plan language in that specific case gave the plan sponsor, in its non-fiduciary "settlor" capacity, control over funding decisions. The DOL's stance suggests a high bar for plaintiffs to plead a breach of duty.

IRS Rules Allow Forfeitures to Reduce Employer Contributions. The IRS has long permitted using forfeitures of defined contribution plans to pay plan expenses or reduce future contributions (and not just to reduce plan expenses), as long as this is documented in the plan. See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 71-313; Rev. Proc. 2016-51 § 6.02(4)(c); IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010). The IRS has long permitted using forfeitures of defined contribution plans to pay plan expenses or reduce future contributions (and not just to reduce plan expenses), as long as this is documented in the plan. See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 71-313; Rev. Proc. 2016-51 § 6.02(4)(c); IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010). Also, Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(b)(1), 88 Fed. Reg. 12282 (Feb. 27, 2023), which may be relied up currently, specifies that for forfeitures under a qualified defined contribution plan, the plan may provide that forfeitures will be used for one or more of the following purposes: (i) to pay plan administrative expenses; (ii) to reduce employer contributions under the plan; and/or (iii) to increase benefits in other participants’ accounts (in a nondiscriminatory fashion) in accordance with plan terms.

Risk Mitigation by Providing Plan Language Giving Order of Priority for Treatment of Forfeitures. To mitigate litigation risk, plan sponsors are advised to amend plan documents to explicitly state the order of forfeiture allocation, such as first reducing employer contributions, followed by covering plan expenses. Sponsors should also ensure forfeitures are used promptly to avoid issues with unallocated funds, in light of proposed Treasury regulations that could impose a deadline of December 31, 2025, for compliance.

 

 



[1]  Rev. Rul. 80–155, 1980–1 CB 84, discusses distribution of forfeitures with respect to distributions to participants and that plans should be valued at least annually. As noted in the Preamble, an IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010) noted that although some defined contribution have forfeited amounts in a plan suspense account accumulating over several years, the Internal Revenue Code does not allow this practice, and it is advisable that no forfeitures in a suspense account should remain unallocated beyond the end of the plan year in which they occurred or the immediately succeeding plan year, and the treatment of the forfeitures should be described in the plan.

 

2027 Cost of Living Adjustments for Retirement and Benefit Plans

  2027 BENEFIT PLAN COST-OF-LIVING ADJUSTMENTS *   Charles C. Shulman, Esq. 201-357-0577 212-380-3834 cshulman@ebeclaw.com The chart b...