Right to a Jury Trial in ERISA Cases
Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
201.357.0577
Published in Journal of Pension Planning & Compliance (WK, Winter 2026)
copy at https://drive.google.com/file/d/11PU_wpBJNl-PZmAMO3bfVLphahKqzMlI/
1. Right
to Jury Trial in ERISA Legal Claims
ERISA
does not explicitly address a plaintiff’s right to a jury trial, and its
legislative history provides no clarification. Federal courts have looked to
the Seventh Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which guarantees the right to a
jury trial in federal common law cases, but not in equitable cases.
Historically, most ERISA claims have been viewed as equitable or partially
equitable and not entitled to a jury trial. However, some recent cases granted
jury trial requests for ERISA claims that seek benefits under the plan or seek
to make the plan whole for monetary losses due to fiduciary breaches.
2. Jury Trials in Legal but Not Equitable Claims
Federal Caselaw
Holds that the Right to a Jury Trial is for Legal but Not Equitable Claims. The Supreme Court has addressed
the issue of the right to a jury trial for legal but not equitable claims on a
number of occasions. For example, in the recent case of Securities and Exchange
Commission v. Jarkesy, 603 U.S. 109 (2024), the Court held that that the SEC's
pursuit of civil penalties in securities fraud cases even within an
administrative setting, was still considered a legal claim, not an equitable
claim, and therefore the defendants could assert their right to a jury trial.
Two-Part Test to Determine if Right to Jury Trial Exists.
To determine whether a particular action will resolve legal rights or
equitable rights, courts examine both the nature of the issues involved and the
remedy sought. See, e.g., Granfinanciera, S.A. v. Nordberg, 492
U.S. 33, 42 (1989), holding that Granfinanciera, S.A. had the right
to a jury trial when sued by the trustee in bankruptcy to recover
allegedly fraudulent monetary transfer, stated that there are two tests to
determine if a jury trial is allowed: (i) the court compares the statutory
action to 18th-century actions brought in the courts of England prior to the
merger of the courts of law and equity; and (ii) the court examines the remedy
sought and determine whether it is legal or equitable in nature. The
Court noted here and in other cases that the second test is more important than
the first.
3. Jury Trial for ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) Denial of Benefits Claims
Cases Denying Jury Trial for ERISA
§ 502(a)(1)(B) Claims for Benefits under the Plan. Most cases have denied jury trials
for an ERISA denial of benefits claim under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), viewing such
claims as equitable, similar to enforcing a trust. Under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), a
civil action may be brought by a participant or beneficiary to recover benefits
due under the terms of his plan, to enforce his or her rights under the terms
of the plan, or to clarify his or her rights to future benefits under the terms
of the plan. For examples of cases that have denied jury trials in §
502(a)(1)(B) denial of benefits claims because they involve primarily equitable
claims, see, e.g., Kramer v. American Electric Power Executive Severance Plan,
128 F.4th 739 (6th Cir. 2025) (employee brought action under ERISA §
502(a)(1)(B) for denial of severance benefits under executive severance plan and
interference under ERISA; plaintiff asserted constitutional right to a jury
trial for ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) denial of benefits claim; court held that ERISA
claim for denial-of-benefits is equitable in nature; thus, plaintiff was not
entitled to a jury trial on ERISA claim for benefits); Graham v. Hartford Life
& Accident Ins. Co., 589 F.3d 1345 (10th Cir. 2009) (the Seventh Amendment
guarantees no right to a jury trial in an ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) action for
benefits because the relief is equitable rather than legal); Wilkins v. Baptist
Healthcare Sys. Inc., 150 F.3d 609, 616 (6th Cir. 1998) (former employee
brought ERISA claim against employer and benefit plan administrator, alleging
that the administrator's denial of disability benefits violated ERISA; court
held that a claim for denial of benefits was not a case for money damages and
therefore plaintiff was not entitled to a jury trial); Biggers v. Wittek
Industries, Inc., 4 F.3d 291 (4th Cir. 1993) (claim for benefits under an ERISA
welfare plan was covered by ERISA, and because ERISA preempts his common law
contract claim, the claim should have been tried by the court under the
principles of ERISA); Bair v. General Motors Corp., 895 F.2d 1094 (6th
Cir. 1990) (former employee sued former employer under ERISA, seeking special
early retirement benefit; court rejected appellant's argument that he was
entitled to a jury merely because issues of contract law are involved in his
claim).
Some Cases Allowing Jury Trials for ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) Denial
of Benefits Claims. Some cases have held that jury trial requests were
allowed even in claims for benefits under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), as they were
held to involve legal claims, like claims for damages. See, e.g., Cox v.
Keystone Carbon Co., 861 F.2d 390 (3d Cir.1988) (court acknowledged the
difference between the relief provided ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), which is “legal,”
and the relief provided ERISA § 502(a)(3)(A) & (B), which is “equitable,” citing
Tull v. United States, 481 U.S. 412 (1987); remanded to district court to determine
whether the § 502(a)(1)(B) claim was presented to it and if so, whether he was
entitled to a jury trial thereunder); Rhodes v. Piggly Wiggly Alabama
Distributing Co., Inc., 741 F. Supp. 1542 (N.D. Ala. 1990) (an action under
ERISA § 502(a)(1) is legal in nature and there is a Seventh Amendment right to
jury trial).
4. Fiduciary Breach Claims under ERISA § 502(a)(2) are Held by Most
Courts to be Equitable Claims Not Entitled to a Jury Trial
With regard to ERISA fiduciary claims under ERISA §
502(a)(2) to remedy fiduciary breaches under ERISA § 409(a), most courts have
held that ERISA fiduciary claims are equitable in nature and are not entitled
to a jury trial. See,
e.g., Acument Global Technologies, Inc.. v. Towers Watson & Co., 998 F. Supp.
2d 111 (S.D.N.Y. 2014) (rejecting jury demand in ERISA fiduciary breach case
because the remedy sought was the classic remedy against a fiduciary, namely, a
surcharge to repair the damage his breach of duty inflicted upon the corpus that
the fiduciary was charged to protect, which is an equitable claim); Bauer-Ramazani
v. Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America-College Retirement and
Equities Fund, No. 1:09–CV–190, 2013 WL 6189802 (D. Vermont 2013) (granting motion to strike jury
demand in ERISA claim for breach of fiduciary duty, because the remedy plaintiffs
seek under ERISA, the value of the use of the plan assets and disgorgement of
any investment profits made through the use of plaintiffs’ funds, are equitable
in nature); Carver v. Bank of New York Mellon, No. 15-CV-10180, 2017 WL 1208598 (S.D.N.Y. 2017) (court
concludes that the remedy sought by plaintiffs for defendants' alleged breach
of fiduciary duty is equitable in nature; defendants' motion to strike plaintiffs'
demand for a jury trial was therefore granted); Divane v. Northwestern
University, 953 F.3d 980 (7th Cir. 2020), vacated on other grounds, 142 S. Ct.
737 (2022) (court stated there would be no right to jury trial for fiduciary
claim); In Re First American Corp. ERISA Litigation, No. SACV
07-01357-JVS, 2009 WL 536254
(C.D. Cal. 2009) (overwhelming weight of authority in the federal courts holds
that actions under ERISA § 502(a)(2) by participant, beneficiaries or
fiduciaries to remedy alleged fiduciary violations of ERISA § 409(a) are
equitable in nature and have no 7th Amendment jury trial right); Harmon v.
Shell Oil Co., No. 3:20-cv-00021, 2023 WL 2474503 (S.D. Tex. Mar. 13, 2023) (given the equitable nature
of the claims and relief that plaintiffs seek, court denied jury request); Popovchak
v. UnitedHealth Group Inc., 692 F.Supp.3d 392, (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 19, 2023) (suit against claims administrators alleging failure
to adequately reimburse beneficiaries for medical services in violation of plan
and their fiduciary duties; court held beneficiaries adequately alleged that
claims administrators breached their fiduciary duty of loyalty; beneficiaries
adequately alleged losses resulting from administrators' alleged conduct; and
beneficiaries did not have Seventh Amendment right to jury trial with regard to
breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims, because it was not clear whether plaintiffs
sought legal damages for their fiduciary duty claims, and the Second Circuit
has long held that ERISA benefits claims do not trigger the right to a jury
trial, the court grants defendants’ motion to strike plaintiffs’ jury demand
without prejudice).
5. Several Recent District Court Cases in the Second Circuit Have Allowed
Jury Trials even for Fiduciary Breach Claims under ERISA § 502(a)(2)
Three recent district court decisions in the Second Circuit have
granted jury trials in ERISA fiduciary breach cases.
a. Jury Trial Allowed in Garthwait v. Eversource
Energy Service Company (D. Conn.) and rather than go to Jury Trial, Defendants
Settled for $15 Million. In Garthwait
v. Eversource Energy Service Company, No. 3:20-CV-00902, 2022 WL 17484817 (JCH)
(D. Conn. Dec. 7, 2022), the court allowed a jury trial for the plaintiffs'
claim for Eversource to restore (“make good”) any losses caused by breaches of
fiduciary duty related to the company's 401(k) plan. In that case, participants
in the 401(k) plan alleged breach of fiduciary duty by allowing underperforming
investments in the 401(k) plan's choice of funds. The court held that the make-good
claim was a legal remedy rather than an equitable remedy because it sought
monetary damages to compensate for the losses caused by the alleged breaches,
and therefore plaintiffs request for a jury trial with respect to the make-good
claims was valid. The case was
subsequently prepared for a jury trial scheduled for April 2023, but as a
result of the risks of a jury trial the parties reached a $15 million
settlement in September, 2023.
b. Jury Trial Allowed in Vellali v. Yale
University (D. Conn.) but Jury Acquitted on Basis of “Could Have” Standard; Plaintiffs
Appealing to Second Circuit. In Vellali v. Yale University, 662 F.Supp.3d
238 (D. Conn. Mar. 17, 2023), a class of participants in Yale University's
403(b) Retirement Account Plan brought suit under ERISA § 502(a)(2) against the
plan fiduciaries for breach of fiduciary duties and other ERISA claims in
connection with alleged excessive recordkeeping and administrative fees, noting
that the plan used multiple recordkeepers, and selected an imprudent choice of investment
funds. The plaintiffs made a jury request. The district court stated that the
remedy is legal in nature since they seek to recover damages out of the
defendant's assets rather than to recover specifically identifiable funds, and
the court therefore held that the plaintiffs have the right to a jury trial in
this case on their claims for money damages.
The jury in the Vellali v. Yale
University case found in June 2023 that Yale University fiduciaries had
breached their fiduciary duty of prudence by allowing unreasonable
recordkeeping and administrative fees, but that the plaintiffs didn't prove any
resulting damages since Yale University demonstrated that a prudent fiduciary
"could have" made the same decisions as to recordkeeping and
administrative fees. The jury also sided with Yale University on the
appropriateness of investment monitoring and share class selection. The
plaintiffs appealed to the Second Circuit claiming that the jury instructions
in the trial did not adequately guide the jury on how to assess damages,
specifically regarding the "could have" versus "would have"
standard for determining if a prudent fiduciary would have made the same
decisions as the defendants. The appeal is pending.
c. Jury Trial Allowed in Khan v. Board of
Directors of Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan (S.D.N.Y.) and Jury Awarded $38
million for Unreasonable Recordkeeping and Administrative Fees. In Khan v.
Board of Directors of Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan, No. 20-CV-07561, 2023
WL 6237862 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 26, 2023), participants in the Pentegra Defined
Contribution Plan for Financial Institutions (a pooled 401(k) plan) brought
suit under ERISA § 502(a)(2)
alleging that plan fiduciaries at Pentegra and the Board breached their ERISA
fiduciary duties by allowing unreasonable recordkeeping and administrative fees.
The plaintiffs amended their claim to request a jury trial. The Southern
District of New York in the 2023 case found that the ERISA § 502(a)(2) claim against the fiduciaries
involves legal and equitable claims, and therefore held that the case should be
bifurcated with the claim for money damages being tried before a jury, and the
remaining equitable claims and prohibited transaction claims should be tried
before the court.
On April 23, 2025, a jury in the U.S. District
Court for the Southern District of New York rendered a unanimous verdict in
Khan v. Board of Directors of Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan, that the
defendants breached their fiduciary duties under ERISA in connection with
administration and fees charged for participation in the Pentegra pooled 401(k)
plan, and as a result, the jury awarded the plaintiffs damages exceeding $38
million. A court decision regarding the equitable and prohibited transaction
claims had not yet been issued, and according to a May 2, 2025 S.D.N.Y. court
order, the parties in Khan v. Board of Directors of Pentegra Defined
Contribution Plan, have reached a settlement in principle for the remaining
claims.
6. Points to Consider in Light of Possibility of Jury Trials for
Excessive Fee Cases
● The intricacies of ERISA excessive fee cases
make jury trials particularly unpredictable.
● In light of the possibility of a jury trial
in excessive fee cases, increased emphasis and care should be taken in the
selection and overseeing of service providers and in reviewing the fee
structures from time to time.
● RFPs from multiple recordkeepers should be
compared.
● 401(k) plan investment funds should be
selected and monitored based on advice of independent financial advisors, and
the funds’ returns and risks should be benchmarked.
● Recordkeepers with a relationship with the plan
sponsor should be avoided.
● It should be interesting to see if this
trend to allow jury trials in ERISA fiduciary excessive fee cases spreads
beyond the Second Circuit.
