Profits, Options, Phantoms and Other Equity-Based Awards
Full article Profits, Options, Phantoms and Other Equity-Based Awards, published in Journal of Deferred Compensation (WK Summer 2022) See copy at: https://drive.google.com/file/d/19eBhlDz7nz0BCBKSy57Uh3lTmbhl-6zM/
Equity-based compensation allows employers to reward management, employees and other service providers for increasing a company's value, often without an immediate cash expenditure. The available arrangements differ considerably in their tax treatment, ownership rights, administrative requirements and incentives. This article compares seven principal types of equity-based and performance awards, emphasizing their practical advantages and disadvantages.
1. Profits Interests
Profits interests have become a popular means of compensating management in private equity transactions and other businesses organized as partnerships or limited liability companies taxed as partnerships. A profits interest provides a share of future appreciation and profits, generally after existing investors have recovered their capital investment and achieved a specified return, such as a preferred internal rate of return (IRR). Unlike a capital interest, it ordinarily has no liquidation value when granted.
Tax treatment. Under Rev. Proc. 93-27, 1993-2 C.B. 343, the receipt of a qualifying profits interest is generally not taxable. The revenue procedure's favorable treatment does not apply if (1) the interest relates to a substantially certain and predictable income stream, (2) the recipient disposes of the interest within two years, or (3) the interest is a limited partnership interest in a publicly traded partnership.
Rev. Proc. 2001-43, 2001-2 C.B. 191, extends this treatment to substantially nonvested profits interests, provided that the recipient is treated as a partner from the grant date, takes into account the distributive share of partnership income or loss, and neither the partnership nor its partners deducts the interest's value as compensation.
Some practitioners recommend a protective election under IRC § 83(b) within 30 days after the grant of an unvested profits interest, particularly where the interest's qualification for favorable treatment is uncertain.
A subsequent sale of a profits interest may produce long-term capital gain, subject to the applicable holding period and rules governing the character of partnership income and gain. Although the usual long-term capital gain holding period exceeds one year, Rev. Proc. 93-27 excludes dispositions within two years from its safe harbor. Further, IRC § 1061 generally imposes a three-year holding period for certain applicable partnership interests, including carried interests held by investment managers. A § 83(b) election does not eliminate the requirements of § 1061.
Advantages. Qualifying profits interests can provide substantial appreciation taxed at capital gain rates without compensation income at grant or vesting. They generally are not subject to IRC § 409A, may be structured without voting rights, and permit considerable flexibility in allocating future profits. Unlike cash compensation, a qualifying grant generally produces no corresponding compensation deduction for the partnership.
Disadvantages and administrative considerations. Profits interests involve genuine ownership and complicated partnership tax consequences. Recipients generally become partners rather than employees of the issuing partnership, receive Schedules K-1 instead of Forms W-2 for their partnership income, and may incur self-employment tax and lose eligibility for certain employee fringe benefits.
One solution is to separate the entity granting profits interests from the entity employing the recipients. For example, a parent partnership may grant profits interests while a separately classified subsidiary employs the individuals and provides wages and employee benefits. A feeder partnership may sometimes serve a similar purpose. These arrangements require careful tax structuring and additional administration.
Moreover, profits interests generally have no value unless the business appreciates sufficiently to satisfy the applicable distribution hurdles. The allocation and distribution formulas can also be complex.
Accounting. Depending on their terms and substance, profits interests may be accounted for as equity-based compensation or performance-based compensation, potentially requiring expense recognition over the service period or remeasurement.
2. Nonqualified Stock Options (NQSOs)
A nonqualified stock option gives the recipient the right to purchase employer stock at a specified exercise price during a stated period. To qualify for the customary stock-right exemption from IRC § 409A, the exercise price generally must equal or exceed the stock's fair market value on the grant date, and the option must satisfy other regulatory conditions.
Tax treatment. NQSOs generally produce no taxable income at grant or vesting. Upon exercise, the excess of the stock's fair market value over the exercise price is ordinary compensation income, generally subject to employment taxes. The employer ordinarily receives a corresponding tax deduction. Subsequent appreciation is taxed as capital gain when the stock is sold, with long-term treatment if the applicable holding period is satisfied.
IRC § 83(i) permits certain employees of qualifying private corporations with broad-based equity programs to defer income recognition on qualifying stock acquired through option exercises for up to five years. The election is subject to substantial restrictions and generally is unavailable to senior executives and certain other employees.
Advantages. NQSOs reward appreciation without an employer cash expenditure at grant. Recipients generally may decide when to exercise, and options may be awarded to employees, directors and independent contractors. They can also be granted before employment begins, unlike incentive stock options.
Disadvantages. Options become economically unattractive when the share price falls below the exercise price. Exercise may require substantial cash, although cashless exercise arrangements may be available. Recipients incur ordinary income tax on exercise, potentially before receiving sale proceeds, and privately held companies face valuation and liquidity challenges.
Accounting. Option grant-date fair value, generally determined using an option-pricing model, is recognized as compensation expense over the applicable vesting period.
3. Incentive Stock Options (ISOs)
Incentive stock options provide more favorable tax treatment than NQSOs but are subject to the statutory requirements of IRC §§ 421 and 422.
ISOs may be granted only to employees of qualifying corporations. The exercise price must be at least fair market value when granted, or 110% of fair market value for certain shareholders owning more than 10% of the corporation. The plan must receive shareholder approval, and options must generally be exercised within ten years after grant, reduced to five years for 10% shareholders.
The aggregate grant-date fair market value of stock underlying ISOs first exercisable by an employee in any calendar year is limited to $100,000. Options exceeding the limit are treated as nonqualified options to that extent.
Tax treatment. Unlike an NQSO, an ISO generally produces no regular federal income tax upon exercise, although the spread may be included for alternative minimum tax (AMT) purposes. If the employee holds the shares for more than one year after exercise and more than two years after grant, the appreciation generally qualifies for long-term capital gain treatment.
The employer ordinarily receives no compensation deduction on a qualifying disposition. However, if the employee disposes of the shares before satisfying the holding periods, part of the gain may be treated as ordinary compensation income, with a corresponding employer deduction.
Advantages and disadvantages. ISOs can provide substantial capital gain benefits without ordinary income tax at exercise. However, the AMT exposure, holding periods, statutory limitations and absence of an employer deduction reduce their attractiveness. Recipients generally must remain employed until no more than three months before exercise, subject to statutory exceptions. ISOs also cannot be issued with respect to ownership interests in an entity taxed as a partnership.
The accounting treatment generally parallels that of NQSOs.
4. Restricted Stock Awards
Restricted stock consists of actual company shares transferred to an employee or other service provider, subject to forfeiture until specified vesting conditions are satisfied. Vesting generally depends on continued service, performance goals or both.
Unlike stock options, restricted shares retain value even if the stock price declines. Recipients may also receive voting and dividend rights from the grant date, depending on the award terms.
Tax treatment. Under IRC § 83(a), restricted stock ordinarily is not taxable upon grant but becomes taxable as ordinary compensation income when substantially vested. The taxable amount generally equals the fair market value of the shares, less any amount paid by the recipient. The employer receives a corresponding deduction, subject to applicable limitations.
Alternatively, the recipient may make an election under IRC § 83(b) within 30 days after the transfer, recognizing the value of the stock at grant rather than vesting. Subsequent appreciation may then qualify for long-term capital gain treatment upon sale.
The principal disadvantage of a § 83(b) election is that the recipient pays tax at grant without assurance that the shares will vest or retain their value. If the stock is later forfeited, the previously paid income tax generally is not recoverable.
Advantages. Restricted stock provides immediate equity ownership, greater downside value than options and potential capital gain treatment on appreciation following an effective § 83(b) election. Actual transfers of restricted stock generally are outside IRC § 409A.
Disadvantages. Tax at vesting may create a liquidity problem, particularly in private companies. Voting and dividend rights may also complicate the company's ownership arrangements, and restricted shares cause actual shareholder dilution.
Accounting. Restricted stock generally is accounted for as equity-based compensation, with expense recognized over the requisite service period.
5. Phantom Stock and Restricted Stock Units (RSUs)
Phantom stock and restricted stock units provide compensation measured by the value of company shares without transferring actual ownership at grant. Both generally represent unfunded, unsecured contractual promises to make a payment at a future date.
RSUs typically settle in employer stock, while phantom stock ordinarily settles in cash. Vesting generally depends on continued service, performance goals or a combination of both.
Tax treatment. Neither arrangement ordinarily produces taxable income at grant. The recipient generally recognizes ordinary compensation income when cash or shares are delivered, and the employer ordinarily receives a corresponding deduction. Because no property is transferred at grant, a § 83(b) election is unavailable.
Phantom stock and RSUs must comply with or qualify for an exemption from IRC § 409A. One common approach is to require settlement within the short-term deferral period, generally no later than 2½ months after the end of the applicable taxable year in which the award is no longer subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture. Awards with later settlement dates must generally comply with § 409A's restrictions on payment timing and acceleration.
Employment taxes may arise at vesting even when settlement is deferred, under the special timing rules for nonqualified deferred compensation.
Advantages. Phantom stock and RSUs provide incentives tied to company value without requiring the recipient to purchase shares. Phantom stock is particularly useful for closely held businesses that wish to reward employees without admitting additional shareholders or relinquishing voting control. Income tax generally is postponed until settlement.
Disadvantages. Payments are taxed as ordinary compensation rather than capital gain. Participants generally do not obtain shareholder rights before settlement, although dividend equivalents may be provided. IRC § 409A also limits flexibility in determining payment dates and accelerating distributions.
Accounting. Equity-settled RSUs generally involve grant-date fair-value accounting, while cash-settled phantom awards may require periodic liability remeasurement.
6. Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)
Stock appreciation rights give recipients the right to receive the increase in the value of specified company shares between grant and exercise, ordinarily payable in cash or stock.
SARs are economically similar to stock options, but recipients need not pay an exercise price to obtain the appreciation.
Tax treatment. A SAR generally is not taxable at grant or vesting. Upon exercise or settlement, the amount received is ordinary compensation income, ordinarily giving rise to a corresponding employer deduction.
SARs may qualify for an exemption from IRC § 409A if the exercise price or base value is at least the underlying stock's fair market value on the grant date, the underlying stock satisfies the service-recipient-stock requirements, and the award does not provide an additional deferral feature.
Advantages. SARs reward stock appreciation without requiring recipients to finance an exercise price or become shareholders. Cash-settled SARs also avoid issuing additional shares.
Disadvantages. Like stock options, SARs provide limited incentives when company value does not appreciate. Payments are taxed as ordinary compensation, and the employer may incur a substantial cash obligation upon settlement. Valuation and § 409A compliance can be particularly important for private companies.
Accounting. SAR expense generally is recognized over the vesting period, with additional remeasurement required for cash-settled liability awards.
7. Performance Awards and Bonuses
Performance awards provide cash or stock compensation upon attainment of specified individual, business-unit or company-wide goals. The terms generally establish eligibility, performance measures, threshold and target awards, and treatment upon termination of employment or a change in control.
Performance awards are particularly useful where an employer wishes to reward specific business results, such as profitability, revenue growth, investment returns or other measurable objectives, without necessarily granting actual equity.
Tax treatment. Performance bonuses generally are taxable as ordinary compensation when paid, with a corresponding employer deduction subject to applicable limitations.
Awards that are paid within the short-term deferral period generally are exempt from IRC § 409A. Awards involving longer deferrals must comply with § 409A, including its requirements governing payment events and restrictions on acceleration. Employment taxes may apply at vesting even if payment is deferred.
Advantages. Performance awards can be tailored to specific business objectives, encourage accountability and avoid issuing additional equity. They also may be structured to balance annual and long-term performance goals.
Disadvantages. Performance standards and payout calculations can become complicated, particularly where several financial or operational measures are involved. Awards may lose their retention value if the performance goals appear unattainable. Long-term arrangements also require careful § 409A drafting.
Accounting. Cash performance bonuses generally are accrued when payment becomes probable and reasonably estimable. Equity-settled performance awards ordinarily are accounted for under the applicable share-based compensation rules.
Conclusion
The appropriate form of equity-based compensation depends on the employer's ownership structure, tax objectives, liquidity, willingness to dilute existing shareholders and desired incentive.
Profits interests can provide particularly favorable tax treatment for businesses taxed as partnerships, but create ownership and administrative complications. NQSOs and SARs reward future appreciation without transferring immediate ownership. ISOs offer potentially favorable capital gain treatment but impose significant statutory restrictions. Restricted stock provides actual ownership and the possibility of capital gain treatment through a § 83(b) election. Phantom stock and RSUs provide equity-linked incentives without immediate ownership, while performance awards permit employers to target particular business objectives.
In selecting among these arrangements, the tax consequences to the recipient and employer, the requirements of IRC §§ 83 and 409A, and the practical costs of administration should be considered together.
See https://drive.google.com/file/d/19eBhlDz7nz0BCBKSy57Uh3lTmbhl-6zM/
