By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
201.357.0577
March, 2026
Recent court decisions have effectively nullified the Department of Labor’s 2024 Retirement Security Rule. Two federal courts stayed the rule, finding that the DOL likely exceeded its authority, and in November 2025 the DOL withdrew its appeals. In March 2026, the DOL published a notice recognizing the judicial vacatur of the 2024 Retirement Security Rule. As a result, fiduciary status for investment advice continues to be governed by the reinstated 1975 five-part test and the original version of PTE 2020-02, alongside the SEC’s Regulation Best Interest.
The Department of Labor’s effort to revise the fiduciary investment-advice standard has become a recurring subject of rulemaking and litigation. Major definitional changes were proposed under successive presidential administrations. The most recent development came in March 2026, when the DOL published a notice recognizing the judicial vacatur of the 2024 Retirement Security Rule. As a result, the 2024 rule and its accompanying amendments to the prohibited-transaction exemptions never took effect. ERISA fiduciary advice therefore continues to be governed by the 1975 five-part test and the reinstated original PTE 2020-02.
I. The 1975 Rule and the 2016 Fiduciary Rule
ERISA’s investment-advice fiduciary definition originates in 1975, when the Ford Administration adopted a regulation providing that a person is a fiduciary only if all elements of a five-part test are satisfied. 40 Fed. Reg. 50842 (Oct. 31, 1975); DOL Reg. § 2510.3-21(c). The 1975 five-part test dictates that a person providing investment advice for a fee is a fiduciary with respect to a plan’s or IRA’s assets only if the advice (i) concerns the value or sale of investment property, (ii) is given on a regular basis, (iii) is provided under a mutual understanding that it will serve as (iv) a primary basis for the retirement investment decision, and (v) is individualized to the investor.
The 2016 Fiduciary Rule replaced the 1975 rule. The 2016 rule imposed fiduciary status when a person made an investment recommendation regarding retirement plan or IRA assets, including one-time advice such as rollovers, under circumstances where the adviser either (i) acknowledged acting as an ERISA fiduciary or (ii) provided advice under an agreement that the advice was based on the recipient’s particular needs. This expansion brought brokers, insurance agents, and others, who were previously held only to a lower suitability standard, under ERISA’s stringent duties of care and loyalty, thereby protecting retirement savers from conflicted advice. To allow financial institutions to continue receiving common forms of compensation, such as commissions, the rule introduced new prohibited-transaction class exemptions, most notably the Best Interest Contract Exemption (BICE), which mandated adherence to Impartial Conduct Standards and required a written contract acknowledging fiduciary status. 81 Fed. Reg. 21002 (Apr. 8, 2016).
However, in 2018, the Fifth Circuit vacated the 2016 Fiduciary Rule in full, holding that the DOL exceeded its statutory authority. Chamber of Commerce v. U.S. DOL, 885 F.3d 360 (5th Cir. 2018).
During the first Trump Administration, the DOL issued 2020 technical amendments to DOL Reg. § 2510.3-21, removing the vacated 2016 Fiduciary Rule from the regulations and reinstating the 1975 test. See 85 Fed. Reg. 40589 (July 7, 2020).
At the same time, the DOL adopted PTE 2020-02, Improving Investment Advice for Workers & Retirees, 85 Fed. Reg. 82798 (Dec. 18, 2020). This exemption remains operative.
In 2019, the Securities and Exchange Commission adopted Regulation Best Interest (“Reg BI”), requiring broker-dealers, when making recommendations to retail customers, to act in the customer’s best interest and not place their own financial interests ahead of the investor’s. Reg BI created a federal securities-law “best interest” standard distinct from the ERISA fiduciary definition. See Regulation Best Interest, Exchange Act Release No. 34-86031, 84 Fed. Reg. 33318 (July 12, 2019). Reg BI remains in effect.
II. The 2024 Retirement Security Rule
In April 2024, under the Biden Administration, the DOL issued the 2024 Retirement Security Rule, which was intended to replace the 1975 five-part test with a modernized fiduciary definition based on adviser representations and investor expectations. Retirement Security Rule—Definition of an Investment Advice Fiduciary, 89 Fed. Reg. 32122 (Apr. 25, 2024).
Under the 2024 Retirement Security Rule’s three-element test, a financial professional would become an ERISA fiduciary if (i) an investment recommendation was made to a retirement investor, (ii) it was provided for a fee, and (iii) the adviser either affirmatively stated fiduciary status or held itself out as a trusted adviser providing individualized best-interest guidance. The rule also included amendments to PTE 2020-02 designed to standardize conduct requirements across advisory and insurance channels.
These changes were scheduled to take effect on September 23, 2024, but were stayed by litigation.
III. The 2024 Litigation, 2025 Appeal Dismissal, and 2026 Vacatur
Before the 2024 Retirement Security Rule took effect, two federal district courts stayed it. These cases were Federation of Americans for Consumer Choice, Inc. v. DOL, 742 F. Supp. 3d 677 (E.D. Tex. 2024), and American Council of Life Insurers v. DOL, Docket No. 4:24-cv-00482, 2024 WL 3572297 (N.D. Tex. 2024). Both courts concluded that the plaintiffs were likely to succeed in arguing that the DOL again exceeded its statutory authority by extending fiduciary obligations to sales practices and one-time recommendations.
In November 2025, the DOL filed an unopposed motion to voluntarily dismiss its consolidated appeals. Mot. to Dismiss, Federation of Americans for Consumer Choice v. DOL, Case Nos. 24-40637 & 24-10890 (5th Cir. Nov. 2025). The Fifth Circuit granted the dismissal on November 28, 2025, leaving the district-court stays intact. The DOL then published an official Notice of Court Vacatur, 91 Fed. Reg. 18213 (Mar. 20, 2026). Because the 2024 exemption amendments were part of the same rulemaking, they also never took effect and were officially void.
IV. Where Things Stand Now and What to Expect
Following the withdrawal of the DOL appeal and the March 2026 notice of vacatur of the 2024 Retirement Security Rule, that rule is not operative. The controlling fiduciary framework remains the 1975 five-part test in DOL Reg. § 2510.3-21, which was restated in the March 2026 notice. 91 Fed. Reg. 18213 (Mar. 20, 2026).
The DOL republished the operative text of PTE 2020-02 in the March notice. It did not include the preamble sections that courts had invalidated. Nevertheless, financial institutions must continue navigating the practical overlap between ERISA fiduciary standards and the SEC’s 2019 Regulation Best Interest rule, 84 Fed. Reg. 33318 (July 12, 2019).
Addendum
Further developments in April 2026 clarified the application of the reinstated 1975 five-part test to rollover recommendations.
In its March 20, 2026 notice, the DOL not only restored the 1975 fiduciary definition but also concluded that the entire preamble to PTE 2020-02 was effectively vacated. Although federal courts had expressly invalidated only portions of that preamble, the DOL determined that the remaining interpretive guidance was too closely intertwined with the invalidated provisions to be reliable. The operative provisions of PTE 2020-02, however, remain in effect. 91 Fed. Reg. 13503, 13504–05 (Mar. 20, 2026).
A further development occurred on April 24, 2026, when the DOL and the Federation of Americans for Consumer Choice filed a joint stipulation dismissing litigation challenging the DOL's 2020 interpretation of rollover advice. The stipulation confirmed that the DOL had reinstated Advisory Opinion 2005-23A (Dec. 7, 2005), commonly known as the Deseret Letter, and would no longer rely on the broader interpretation contained in the 2020 preamble.
Under that advisory opinion, a recommendation by a person who is not otherwise a plan fiduciary to roll assets from an ERISA plan into an IRA generally does not, standing alone, constitute fiduciary investment advice with respect to the plan. The analysis remains subject to the facts and circumstances and the requirements of the 1975 five-part test.
These developments substantially narrow the circumstances in which a one-time rollover recommendation establishes fiduciary status under ERISA. They do not, however, eliminate fiduciary obligations where the five-part test is otherwise satisfied, nor do they repeal PTE 2020-02. Financial institutions relying on that exemption must continue to satisfy its applicable conditions, including its impartial conduct standards.
The DOL has also stated that it has no current plans to undertake new notice-and-comment rulemaking concerning the definition of investment advice fiduciary. For now, the reinstated 1975 five-part test, the restored 2005 rollover guidance, and the operative provisions of PTE 2020-02 provide the governing federal framework.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.