Friday, November 7, 2025

Forfeitures in Qualified Plans: (i) Proposed Regulations; and (ii) Fiduciary Class Action Suits

 


Forfeitures in Qualified Plans: (i) Proposed Regulations; and (ii) Fiduciary Class Action Suits

By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.

November 7, 2025

I. Part 1 – 2023 Proposed Regulations Regarding Forfeitures

2023 Proposed Regulations Regarding Forfeitures. The IRS has long permitted using forfeitures of defined contribution plans to pay plan expenses or reduce future contributions (and not just to reduce plan expenses), as long as this is documented in the plan. See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 71-313; Rev. Proc. 2016-51 § 6.02(4)(c); IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010). In February 2023, the IRS issued proposed regulations with specific rules for forfeitures of defined benefit plans and for forfeitures of defined contribution plans. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7, 88 Fed. Reg. 12282 (Feb. 27, 2023). These regulations are proposed to apply for plan years beginning on or after January 1,  2024, once finalized, and they have not yet been finalized. But Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(d) and the Preamble provide that taxpayers may rely on these proposed regulations for periods preceding the effective date of the regulations.

Three Options For Forfeitures In Defined Contributions Plans. The 2023 proposed regulations provide that for forfeitures under a qualified defined contribution plan, the plan must provide that forfeitures will be used for one or more of the following purposes: (i) to pay plan administrative expenses; (ii) to reduce employer contributions under the plan; or (iii) to increase benefits in other participants’ accounts (in a nondiscriminatory fashion) in accordance with plan terms. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(b)(1).

12-Month Deadline to Allocate Forfeitures in Defined Contribution Plans. The 2023 proposed regulations also provide that for defined contribution plans, the forfeitures must be used no later than 12 months following the close of the plan year in which the forfeitures were incurred under the plan, and this rule must be stated in the plan. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(b)(2).[1] As stated in the Preamble, this deadline is intended to simplify administration by providing a single deadline for the use of forfeitures that applies for all types of defined contribution plans and to alleviate administrative burdens that may arise in using or allocating forfeitures if forfeitures are incurred late in a plan year. Forfeitures incurred during any plan year that begins before January 1, 2024, will be treated as having been incurred in the first plan year that begins on or after January 1, 2024. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(c). 

The Preamble gives an example that if there are $25,000 of forfeitures in a plan year, and the plan incurs only $10,000 in plan administrative expenses before the end of the 12-month period following the end of that plan year, there will be $15,000 of forfeitures that remain unused after the deadline established in these proposed regulations, and the plan would incur an operational qualification failure because forfeitures remain unused at the end of the 12-month period following the end of that plan year.

Forfeitures in Defined Benefit Plans may not be Used to Increase Benefits to any Employees under the Plan but are Instead Utilized as an Actuarial Gain That Reduces Future Required Employer Contributions. Code §401(a)(8) provides that a defined benefit plan will not be qualified unless the plan provides that forfeitures must not be applied to increase the benefits any employee would otherwise receive under the plan. The 2023 proposed regulations provide that for forfeitures in defined benefit plans the plan must provide that forfeitures may not be applied to increase the benefits any employee would otherwise receive under the plan, unless there is a plan termination or freeze of contributions the plan. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(a). This rule is also in the original 1963 Treas. Reg. §1.401-7. (The proposed regulations do not contemplate using forfeitures in defined benefit plans to offset plan expenses, because actuarial assumptions regarding future contributions already account for the forfeitures.)

The Proposed 2023 Regulations Provide that Forfeitures in Defined Benefit Plans may be Used to Reduce Future Contributions. Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(a). However, in contrast to the original 1963 regulations, which stated that defined contribution plan forfeitures must be used as soon as possible to reduce the employer’s contributions under the plan, the proposed 2023 regulations have removed this requirement because reasonable actuarial assumptions under the Internal Revenue Code already account for the forfeitures as an actuarial gain that reduces future required employer contributions. Instead, the proposed regulations provide that for defined benefit plans, the effect of forfeitures may be anticipated in determining the costs under the reasonable actuarial assumptions set forth in IRC §§430(h)(1), 431(c)(3) 433(c)(3). Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(a). As noted above, taxpayers may rely on these proposed regulations for periods preceding the effective date of the regulations.

 

II. Part 2. Recent Wave of Litigation re Use of Plan Forfeitures to Reduce Employer Contributions Rather than to Reduce Participant Administrative Expenses

Forfeiture Class Action Litigation. Class action litigation related to retirement plan forfeitures has surged dramatically since late 2023 and continued through 2025. The primary trend involves lawsuits challenging the common practice of using forfeited, unvested employer contributions to offset future employer contributions to the retirement plans (for example the employer match in 401(k) plans), rather than using them to cover plan expenses that otherwise may be charged to participants' accounts. 

Dozens of Class Action Lawsuits. Close to 80 class action lawsuits have been filed since September 2023 in the U.S. regarding use of forfeitures of retirement plans to reduce future contributions rather than to reduce administrative claims that may be charged to participants, including cases against HP Inc., Intuit, JPMorgan Chase and Qualcomm (all discussed below). Plaintiffs argue that the decision on how to use forfeitures, when a plan document provides discretion, is a "fiduciary act" under ERISA. They contend that fiduciaries breach their duty of loyalty and prudence by choosing to benefit the employer (by reducing employer contributions) over plan participants (by reducing participant-borne administrative fees).

Some District Courts Have Summarily Dismissed the Claims and Others Have Allowed Claims to Proceed to Litigation. District court rulings in forfeiture class actions have been inconsistent, with some cases dismissed in favor of plan sponsors. See, e.g., Hutchins v. HP Inc., 767 F. Supp. 3d 912 (N.D. Cal. 2025) (in putative class action by former employee alleging breach of fiduciary duties when plan sponsor decided to use 401(k) plan forfeitures to reduce employer contributions rather than to pay administrative costs, the court found that the employer's use of forfeitures to reduce future employer contributions did not breach fiduciary duties, as it complied with the plan document and ERISA requirements; case is being appealed by the plaintiffs in the Ninth Circuit, and the DOL has filed an amicus brief in favor of HP Inc.); Sievert v. Knight-Swift Transportation, 780 F. Supp. 3d 870 (D. Ariz. 2025) (the court dismissed the suit, finding that the plan document permitted the use of forfeitures to reduce future employer contributions; the decision was further supported by longstanding IRS regulations allowing such practices in defined contribution plans); Wright v. JPMorgan Chase & Co et al., 2025 WL 3798391 (C.D. Cal. June 13, 2025) (dismissed with prejudice so that it cannot be refiled in the district; court ruled that the 401(k) fiduciaries properly followed the plan's explicit terms, which granted discretion to use forfeitures to offset employer contributions).

Others forfeiture class action district court cases have allowed the cases to proceed. Buescher v. North American Lighting, 2:24-cv-02076, 2025 WL 1927503 (C.D. Ill. June 30, 2025) (the court allowed the case to proceed, finding that the plaintiff had sufficiently alleged that the plan committee used an imprudent process in allocating forfeitures, which could support a breach of fiduciary duty claim); Perez-Cruet v. Qualcomm, 23-cv-1890-BEN, 2024 WL 2702207 (S.D. Cal. May 24, 2024) (the court allowed the case to proceed, finding that the use of forfeitures to reduce future employer contributions instead of offsetting plan expenses could have eliminated participant fees, which is partially passed onto employees); Rodriguez v. Intuit, Inc., 744 F. Supp. 3d 935 (N.D. Cal. 2024) (motion to dismiss largely denied; one of the first high-profile companies hit with this type of lawsuit; district court initially denied most of its motion to dismiss in 2024, giving the plaintiffs an early win and validating the legal theory; case ultimately settled in 2025).

The outcomes often hinge on the specific language of the plan documents.

Some Dismissed District Court Cases Are Being Appealed to the Federal Courts of Appeal. Several dismissed forfeiture cases are currently on appeal in the Ninth Circuit (Hutchins v. HP Inc., discussed above), Third Circuit (Cain v. Siemens Corp. and Barragan v. Honeywell Int'l), Eighth Circuit (Matula v. Wells Fargo) and Eleventh Circuit (Cano v. Home Depot, Inc.). These appellate decisions in late 2025 and 2026 will likely bring greater clarity to the legal landscape.

DOL Amicus Brief in Support of Plan Sponsors in Hutchins v. HP Inc. The DOL, in a July 9, 2025 amicus brief No. 25-826 for Hutchins v. HP Inc., before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, on appeal from dismissal by district court in 767 F. Supp. 3d 912 (N.D. Cal. 2025), supported the plan sponsor, stating that while the allocation of expenses is a fiduciary decision, the plan language in that specific case gave the plan sponsor, in its non-fiduciary "settlor" capacity, control over funding decisions. The DOL's stance suggests a high bar for plaintiffs to plead a breach of duty.

IRS Rules Allow Forfeitures to Reduce Employer Contributions. The IRS has long permitted using forfeitures of defined contribution plans to pay plan expenses or reduce future contributions (and not just to reduce plan expenses), as long as this is documented in the plan. See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 71-313; Rev. Proc. 2016-51 § 6.02(4)(c); IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010). The IRS has long permitted using forfeitures of defined contribution plans to pay plan expenses or reduce future contributions (and not just to reduce plan expenses), as long as this is documented in the plan. See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 71-313; Rev. Proc. 2016-51 § 6.02(4)(c); IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010). Also, Prop. Treas. Reg. §1.401-7(b)(1), 88 Fed. Reg. 12282 (Feb. 27, 2023), which may be relied up currently, specifies that for forfeitures under a qualified defined contribution plan, the plan may provide that forfeitures will be used for one or more of the following purposes: (i) to pay plan administrative expenses; (ii) to reduce employer contributions under the plan; and/or (iii) to increase benefits in other participants’ accounts (in a nondiscriminatory fashion) in accordance with plan terms.

Risk Mitigation by Providing Plan Language Giving Order of Priority for Treatment of Forfeitures. To mitigate litigation risk, plan sponsors are advised to amend plan documents to explicitly state the order of forfeiture allocation, such as first reducing employer contributions, followed by covering plan expenses. Sponsors should also ensure forfeitures are used promptly to avoid issues with unallocated funds, in light of proposed Treasury regulations that could impose a deadline of December 31, 2025, for compliance.

 

 



[1]  Rev. Rul. 80–155, 1980–1 CB 84, discusses distribution of forfeitures with respect to distributions to participants and that plans should be valued at least annually. As noted in the Preamble, an IRS newsletter, Retirement News for Employers (Spring 2010) noted that although some defined contribution have forfeited amounts in a plan suspense account accumulating over several years, the Internal Revenue Code does not allow this practice, and it is advisable that no forfeitures in a suspense account should remain unallocated beyond the end of the plan year in which they occurred or the immediately succeeding plan year, and the treatment of the forfeitures should be described in the plan.

 

Monday, October 13, 2025

2025 Executive Order on Democratizing 401(k) Access to Alternative Assets

 


Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
Employee Benefits & Executive Compensation
www.EBECIaw.com cshulman@ebeclaw.com
T. 201.357.0577 M. 212.380.3834

Oct. 13, 2025

On August 7, 2025, President Trump issued an executive order titled “Democratizing Access to Alternative Assets for 401 (k ) Investors”, which directs the Department of Labor to revise existing guidance and consider regulatory changes to facilitate alternative asset inclusion in 401(k) plans.

On June 3, 2020, under the first Trump administration, the DOL issued an Information Letter stating that ERISA does not expressly prohibit private equity investments within a professionally managed asset allocation fund offered in a 401(k) plan. On Dec. 21, 2021, under the Biden administration, the DOL issued a Supplemental Statement that discouraged fiduciaries from considering alternative assets in 401(k) retirement plan investments, casting doubt on the 2020 letter. The 2021 Supplemental Statement warned that fiduciaries of small, individual account plans were not likely suited to evaluate such investments, effectively precluding access for most plan sponsors.

The 2025 Executive Order directs the DOL the SEC to reassess existing fiduciary guidance under ERISA and consider regulatory changes that would enable plan sponsors to include alternative assets in professionally managed asset allocation funds. It also calls for the creation of safe harbor provisions to protect fiduciaries from excessive

litigation when making prudent investment decisions involving alternative assets, with the goal of ensuring that fiduciaries can balance the potential for higher long-term returns and diversification against the risks and costs associated with these complex investments. It mandates proposing rules or safe harbors within 180 days to reduce litigation risks, which deter fiduciaries due to fears of excessive fee or underperformance lawsuits.

The Executive Order defines “alternative assets” broadly, including private market investments, real estate holdings,

md longevity risk-sharing pools.

•                                                                          ■>er 21 st, 2021, Supplemental Statement that discouraged

■ (k) plans.

The Executive Order signals a policy shift to expand 401(k) access to alternative assets by reducing regulatory and litigation barriers. However, while awaiting further regulatory clarity from the government and even after such guidance, there are certain factors to keep in mind when considering adding alternative investments to a 401(k)

plan:

1.   ERISA’s core fiduciary duties of prudence, loyalty, and diversification remain unchanged, and fiduciaries must act solely in participants’ best interests, using care, skill, and diligence when considering alternative assets like private equity, real estate, or cryptocurrencies.

2.   Future DOL guidance under the Trump administration may be challenged in court or reversed by a future administration.

3.   There is still a potential for increased fiduciary liability for plan administrators due to (i) the risk that the alternative investments will significantly underperform or lead to participant losses, and (ii) inherently complex and illiquid nature of alternative assets and (iii) the higher fees.

4.   A thorough , well-documented process for selecting and monitoring investments is critical to comply with ERISA’s fiduciary obligation and help defend against potential litigation.

5.   Plan sponsors and fiduciaries should strengthen due diligence, update investment policy statements, increase participant education and monitor regulatory developments to navigate this evolving landscape.

6.     Congressional action may be needed for significant litigation reform due to ERISA’s private right of action.

7.   Alternative assets pose risks due to illiquidity, high fees, valuation complexities, and volatility, requiring fiduciaries to balance potential returns and diversification benefits against these challenges.

8.   The participant-directed nature of 401(k) plans, which relies on participants making their own investment choices, may not be well suited for alternative assets, which often require sophisticated knowledge and long-

term commitment.

Friday, October 10, 2025

"Affiliated Service Group" Rules for Qualified Plans



 "Affiliated Service Group" Rules for Qualified Plans

By Charles C. Shulman, Esq.

Printed in 51 Journal of Pension Planning and Compliance, no. 4, at 1 (WK, Winter 2026).
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1aCHAi8m-ZuvFysOcIpTQ-kQyWUqxVHr4/edit 

 October 10, 2025 (updated 3/10/26)

This article explains when separate service or management entities are treated as a single employer under Internal Revenue Code § 414(m) for qualified plan and certain welfare plan purposes. It traces the origins of the affiliated service group rules, distinguishes them from ERISA controlled group rules, and provides practical guidance on A-Org, B-Org, and management organization affiliated service groups, including ownership attribution and recent statutory developments.

1. Affiliated Service Group Rules Generally and Background

            Under Internal Revenue Code ("Code") § 414(m), employees of trades or businesses that are members of an "affiliated service group" are treated as employed by a single employer, for purposes of nondiscrimination testing and other qualified plan rules under the Code (but not for purposes of liability under Title IV of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act ("ERISA")).

Reason for Enactment of Code § 414(m) Affiliated Service Rules

            Prevention of Nondiscrimination Circumvention. Code § 414(m) was enacted in 1980 to ensure that certain nondiscrimination rules that are intended to prevent qualified plans disproportionately benefiting highly-compensated employees, could not be circumvented through the use of separate entities. Many professionals, relying on the Kiddie-Garland line of decisions, had placed their common-law employees into partnerships composed of their professional service corporations to exclude rank-and-file employees from participation in the qualified retirement plans of the professional corporations.

            Response to Kiddie and Garland Precedents. The affiliated service group rules under Code § 414(m) were enacted as part of the Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1980 in response to two cases—Thomas Kiddie, Inc. v. C.I.R., 69 T.C. 1055 (1978), and Garland v. C.I.R., 73 T.C. 5 (1979), where two sets of physicians incorporated their medical practices as PCs (or in the case of Garland one physician incorporated his medical practice) and these physician PCs (or in the case of Garland one PC and one physician) formed a partnership with the partnership employing the non-doctor employees of the medical practice. The physician PCs were allowed in these cases to set up qualified retirement plans for the physicians even though no qualified retirement plan was set up for the partnership's rank-and-file employees, because, prior to the 1980 legislation, the physician PCs were not aggregated with the partnership medical group for nondiscrimination purposes under the Code rules.

            In response to this perceived abuse, Code § 414(m) was enacted under the Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1980, requiring that certain related service organizations must be treated as a single employer.

            Expansion of Affiliated Service Group Aggregation to Management Service Organizations. The Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 § 246(a) expanded the affiliated service group rules by adding new Code § 414(m)(5) to include a management service organization that regularly performs management functions for another organization (or for a group of related organizations) as an affiliated service group with such organization(s).

2. Where Affiliated Serviced Group Rules are Applied

            Qualified Plan Requirements Subject to Aggregation. Pursuant to Code § 414(m)(4), employees of trades or businesses that are members of an affiliated service group are treated as employed by a single employer for the following qualified plan rules: (i) minimum coverage under Code § 410(b),  nondiscrimination testing under § 401(a)(4) and regulations (including general test and benefits, rights and features test), ADP/ACP testing under § 401(k) & 401(m), minimum participation under § 401(a)(26), minimum participation under § 410, minimum vesting under § 411, annual addition limit under § 415, top-heavy limit under § 416 and compensation limit under § 401(a)(17) (Code §§ 414(m)(4)); and (ii) simplified employee pension (SEP) rules under Code § 408(k) and Simple retirement accounts rules under Code § 408(p) (Code § 414(m)(4)(B)).[1]

            Application to Welfare Benefits and the ACA. The affiliated service group rules are also applicable to the following welfare plan requirements: (i) medical reimbursement plan coverage under Code § 105(h), cafeteria plans under Code § 125, accident and health plan rules of Code § 106 and fringe benefit rules of Code § 132 (Code § 414(t), 105(h)(8) & 125(g)(4)); (ii) Affordable Care Act mandated coverage rules for employers with 50 or more employees on a controlled group basis, to provide affordable healthcare benefits or pay certain penalties under Code § 4980H(a) & (b) (Code § 4980H(c)(2)(C)(i); Treas. Reg. § 54.4980H-1(a)(16)); and most likely (iii) COBRA continuation coverage rules, for although ERISA § 607(4) only references the "controlled group" rules of Code § 414, Code § 414(t) and Rev. Rul. 2003-70 reference Code § 414(b) & (c) and § 414(m).

            Not Applicable to Title IV Liability or § 409A. However, in contrast to ERISA controlled group rules under Code § 414(b) & (c), affiliated service group rules under Code § 414(m) do NOT apply to: (i) liability under Title IV of ERISA (ERISA § 4062(a) only references Code § 414(b) & (c), not (m)); or (ii) Code § 409A restrictions on nonqualified deferred compensation plans (Code § 409A(d)(6) only references Code § 414(b) & (c), not (m)). Also, affiliated service group rules (like controlled group rules) would not apply to: (i) prohibited transaction rules; (ii) other excise taxes; (iii) consequences of plan disqualification; (iv) Title I reporting and disclosure obligations; and (v) contractual liabilities for promised benefits.

3. Controlled Group Rules Separate from Affiliated Service Group Rules

            Distinction Between Controlled Group and ASG Frameworks .Under the Code and ERISA, employees of certain related "controlled group" entities, as defined in § 414(b) & (c) of the Code, are treated as employed by a single employer, for purposes of liability under Title IV of ERISA, qualified plan nondiscrimination testing under the Code and various other rules. For a thorough discussion of the ERISA controlled group rules, see my recent article, "ERISA's 'Controlled Group' Rules – A Timely Review," published in 51 Journal of Pension Planning and Compliance, no. 1, at 1 (WK, Fall 2025).

            Concurrent Application of Multiple Aggregation Standards. Note that the rules for treatment of an "affiliated service group" as a single employer under Code § 414(m) and the rules for treatment of "controlled group" entities as a single employer under Code § 414(b) & (c) are to be applied separately. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-1(a), 48 Fed. Reg. 8293 (Feb. 28, 1983), provides that if aggregation is required under either of Code § 414(b) or 414(c) and also under § 414(m), the requirements with respect to all of the applicable provisions must be satisfied. As interpreted in Tech. Advice Memo. 201715001 (April 14, 2017), both the controlled group set of rules and the affiliated service group of rules must be applied, and therefore Entity 2 could be in the same controlled group of Entity 1 under § 414(c) even though Entity 2 is an affiliated service group of Entity 3. In that case Entity 1 and Entity 2 each had a qualified defined contribution plan, the Code § 415(c) limits would apply on a controlled group aggregated basis.

4. Types of Affiliated Service Groups

            A-Org or B-Org Affiliated Service Groups Under Code § 414(m)(2). An affiliated service group under § 414(m) is a group consisting of:

      i. a "first service organization" ("FSO")—which is a "service organization," and is defined in § 414(m)(3) as an organization whose principal business is the performance of services;

      AND

      ii. one of the following:

      (a) an "A-Org" under § 414(m)(2)(A)—a service organization (i.e., one whose principal business is the performance of services); (1) that is a "shareholder or partner of the FSO" (without regard to the amount of percentage interest), and (2) that "regularly performs services for" the FSO or is "regularly associated with" the FSO in performing services for third parties;

      OR

      (b) a "B-Org" under § 414(m)(2)(B)—any organization other than an A-Org if (1) a "significant portion" of the B-Org's business is the performance of services for the FSO or for an A-Org, and (2) at least 10% of such organization is owned by highly compensated employees[2] of the FSO (both prongs must be met to be a B-Org affiliated service group).

            Organization. The proposed IRS regulations under Code § 414(m)(2) provide that an "organization" under § 414(m) includes a corporation, partnership, sole proprietorship or any other type of entity regardless of its ownership form. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(e)(1), 48 Fed. Reg. 8293 (Feb. 28, 1983).[3]

5. Constructive Ownership

            Application of Attribution Rules. Code § 414(m)(6) and other IRS guidance provides that in determining ownership under § 414(m), the family and entity ownership attribution rules of Code § 318(a) apply.

            Attribution From Entities to Individuals. Stock or partnership interests owned, directly or indirectly, by or for a corporation, partnership, estate, or trust are considered as being owned proportionately by or for its shareholders, partners, or beneficiaries. An individual owning (otherwise than by the application of the rule immediately above) any stock in a corporation or interest in a partnership is treated as owning the stock or partnership interests owned, directly or indirectly, by or for his partner. Code § 318(a)(2). Code § 318(a)(2)(C) looks through to underlying interests owned by a corporation if there is a 50% ownership by a person in the corporation. However, stock owned by or for a partnership or partner will be considered owned proportionately by the partner or owned by the partnership without regard to whether there is a 50% ownership interest.[4]

            Attribution From Individuals to Entities. Under IRC § 318(a)(3)(A) & (B), stock owned by a partner of a  partnership or a beneficiary of an estate is considered owned by the partnership or estate. Similarly, interests owned by a beneficiary of a trust (excluding certain tax-exempt employees' trusts) are attributed to the trust, unless the beneficiary’s interest is a remote contingent interest of 5% or less. IRC § 318(a)(3)(B)(ii). For corporate attribution, if a person owns 50% or more in value of the stock in a corporation, that corporation is considered as owning the stock owned by such person. IRC § 318(a)(3)(C). However, in the case of a partnership, interests held by a partner are attributed to the partnership without regard to whether there is a 50% ownership interest.

            SECURE 2.0 Reforms to Family Attribution. The SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 amended Code § 414(m)(6)(B) to streamline family attribution rules, effective for plan years beginning in 2024, so that: (i) community property laws are ignored when applying family attribution rules under Code § 318, allowing businesses owned by spouses to be treated as separate for aggregation purposes, even in community property states, if there is no direct ownership or management in each other spouse's businesses; and (ii) if stock ownership is not attributed to a spouse due to legal separation (via divorce or separate maintenance decree) under Code § 318(a)(1)(A)(i), it generally will not be attributed to the spouse via minor children (under age 21) under the minor child attribution rule.

6. Determination of Affiliated Service Group Status as Part of Determination Letter Prior to 2017

            Historical Availability of IRS Rulings. Prior to 2017, IRS Form 5300 and Rev. Proc. 2016-6, § 14, provided for IRS determination letter requests for affiliated service group status under Code § 414(m) (but only as part of the process of submitting a qualified plan for a determination as to its qualified status. Instructions to Form 5300). IRS Publication 7005 (last updated April 2016)—Employee Benefit Plans Explanation No. 10 Affiliated Service Group (determination letter flow-chart) was used to assist IRS agents in making affiliated service group determination letter rulings.

            Absence of Independent Private Letter Rulings. Note that even before Rev. Proc. 2017-4, an IRS private letter ruling request, separate from the IRS determination letter requested, was not available for affiliated service group status, as stated in Rev. Proc. 2016-4, § 6.03.

            2017 Elimination of ASG Determinations. Rev. Proc. 2017-4, which modified the procedures for requesting determination letters, provides that beginning in 2017 the IRS will no longer issue determination letters as to whether the plan sponsor is part of an affiliated service group. Rev. Proc. 2017-4, 2017-1 I.R.B. 146, § 2.02 (procedures for requesting determination letters were modified to reflect that employers that maintain individually designed plans may no longer request determination letters on whether a plan sponsor is part of an affiliated service group).

7. A-Org Affiliated Service Group

A-Org Group

            An "A-Org" affiliated service group under § 414(m)(2)(A) is a group consisting of:

      i. a "first service organization" ("FSO")—which is a "service organization," which is defined in § 414(m)(3) as an organization whose principal business is the performance of services;

      AND

      ii. an A-Org under § 414(m)(2)(A)—which is a service organization (i.e., one whose principal business is the performance of services); (1) which is a "shareholder or partner of the FSO" (without regard to the amount of percentage interest), and (2) "regularly performs services for" the FSO or is "regularly associated with" the FSO in performing services for third parties.

Code § 414(m)(2)(A).

De Minimis Ownership of A-Org in FSO

            There is no ownership threshold of the A-org in the FSO, and even a de minimis ownership should suffice.[5]

Standard for A-Org Regularly Performing Services for FSO (or with FSO)

            Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(b) provides that the determination of "regularly performing services for" or "regularly associated with" is made on the basis of facts and circumstances with one factor being the amount of earned income the "A" Org derives from performing services for the FSO or for the third party.

            The proposed regulations give three examples of what regularly performing services or regularly associated means: (1) Where an attorney forms a professional service corporation and that PC is a partner in a law firm, and the PC and the law firm are regularly associated in performing services for third persons, they are affiliated service groups. (2) Where a corporation which is a shareholder of, and regularly performs services for another corporation, and both are service organizations but neither is a professional service corporation, there is no affiliation because there is no FSO. (3) A law firm branch which is a PC and also a partner in the national firm, will be considered affiliates since the branch is a partner in the national law firm and is regularly associated with the national law firm in performance services for third persons. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(b)(3). Examples 1 and 3 imply some clearly "regular" requirement. If only a small portion of the partner or shareholders activities were performed with the FSO it would appear that the "regularly" requirement would not be met.[6]

FSO as Professional Service Corp if A-Org is a Corporation

            IRS proposed regulations provide that for purposes of the A-Org affiliated service group test, if the first service organization is a corporation it will not be an FSO unless it is organized under state law as a "professional service corporation" providing professional services, i.e., services provided by certified or public accountants, actuaries, architects, attorneys, chiropodists, chiropractors, medical doctors, dentists, professional engineers, optometrists, osteopaths, podiatrists, psychologists, and veterinarians. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-1(c), 48 Fed. Reg. 8293 (Feb. 28, 1983). The exemption is pursuant to Code § 414(m) (1). (In contrast, however, with respect to B-Org. affiliated service group test, even if the FSO is a corporation that is not a professional service corporation, it can still be considered to be an FSO.)[7]

Test A-Org in Both Directions

            A-Org (or B-Org) affiliated service group status must be tested in both directions, looking at the possibility that the first entity is the FSO and the second entity is the A-Org, as well as the possibility that the first entity is the A-Org and the second entity is the FSO, because an entity that may not be an FSO may still be an A-Org and vice versa.

Examples of FSO and A-Org Affiliated Service Group

            Example. Dr. Sarah Thompson, a surgeon, is incorporated as Sarah Thompson, MD, PC, and the PC is a partner in Artful Contours Surgical Group. Sarah Thompson, MD, PC is regularly associated with Artful Contours Surgical Group in plastic surgery offered to the public. Artful Contours Surgical Group is an FSO, and Sarah Thompson, MD, PC is an A-Org because it is a partner in Artful Contours Surgical Group and is regularly associated with Artful Contours Surgical Group to perform services for third parties. Accordingly, Sarah Thompson, MD, PC and Artful Contours Surgical Group constitute an affiliated service group and must be treated if they were employed by a single employer under Code § 414(m)(2)(A).

            Traditional Partnership-PC Structure. A typical example of an "A-Org." affiliated service group is a law or medical partnership (FSO) in which one or more of the partners is incorporated (A-Org.). The incorporated partner owns the shares of his professional corporation and is licensed to practice law or medicine under the laws of the state in which he is incorporated. The incorporated partner and the partnership are regularly associated in performing services for third persons (i.e., clients or patients), or the incorporated partner regularly performs services for the partnership.

            Example of Complexities in Imaging and Ancillary Health Services. In the health field and other areas more difficult issues arise. For example, suppose a physician in sole practice owns a limited partnership interest in an imaging facility (i.e., X-ray, MRI, equipment). The imaging facility partnership's profits are based on a charge to patients for the X-ray or imaging procedure; it does not receive any income from the radiologist's charge for interpreting the image. The amount she receives from the facility is not directly related to the number of patients the physician refers to the facility, although the more profit the limited partnership makes, the greater the physician's share. It is possible that the proposed regulations would treat the physician as an A-Org. and the imaging facility partnership an FSO, because the physician is a service organization licensed to practice medicine, and is a partner in another organization which may be a service organization and together they may be viewed as rendering service to third persons. However, it is questionable whether the doctor and the facility are associated in rendering service to third persons since the doctor acts only as a referrer. If the facility were a corporation, rather than a partnership, these issues might not even arise because of the limitation in the proposed regulations, discussed above, that the FSO, if it is incorporated, be a professional service corporation, as that term is defined in the proposed regulations. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c) generally.

A-Org Flowchart

            The following flowchart illustrates the above A-Org affiliated service group rules.

8. B-Org Affiliated Service Group

B-Org

            A "B-Org" affiliated service group under § 414(m)(2)(B) is a group consisting of:

      i. a "first service organization" ("FSO")—which is a "service organization," which is defined in § 414(m)(3) as an organization whose principal business is the performance of services;

      AND

      ii. a B-Org under § 414(m)(2)(B)—which is an organization other than an A-Org if (1) a "significant portion" of the B-Org's business is the performance of services for the FSO or for an A-Org of a type historically performed in such service field by employees, and (2) at least 10% of such organization is owned by highly compensated employees[8] of the FSO. Both prongs must be met to be a B-Org affiliated service group.

Code § 414(m)(2)(B).

Significant Portion of B-Org's Business is Performance of Services of a Type Historically Performed in such Service Field by Employees

The services must be of a type historically performed by employees in the service field of the FSO or the A-Org. The "historically performed" test will be met if it was not unusual for the service to be performed by employees of the organization in that service field in the United States on December 13, 1980. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c)(3).

Proposed regulations provide that "significant portion" is a facts-and-circumstances test but further provides that, if gross receipts constitute less than 5% of all services, such receipts are deemed not to be a significant portion. If gross receipts constitute 10% or more of all receipts, such receipts are deemed to be a significant portion. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c)(2) (proposed in 1983).

A significant portion of the business of the organization is the performance of services for the relevant organization if the "Total Receipts Percentage" is greater than 10%. The Total Receipts Percentage is the ratio of the gross receipts of the organization derived from the FSO and/or A-Organization(s) to the total gross receipts of the organization. If the "Service Receipts Percentage" is less than 5% it will not be considered a significant portion. The Service Receipts Percentage is the ratio of the gross receipts of the organization derived from performing services for the FSO and/or A-Organization(s) to the total gross receipts of the organization derived from performing services. A facts and circumstances test will apply if neither test is met. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c)(2).

10% of B-Org Held by Officers, Highly-Compensated Employees or Owners of FSO or A-Org

As explained in the proposed regulations, 10% or more of the putative B-Org. organization must be held, in the aggregate, by persons who are designated group members (i.e., the officers, highly compensated employees, and the common owners of an organization) of the FSO or the A-Org., determined by applying the constructive ownership rules. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c). A "common owner" is a person who is an owner of a FSO or of an A-Org. if at least 3% of the interests in the organization are, in the aggregate, held by persons who are owners of the putative B-Org., determined using constructive ownership rules. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c). Note that, although Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c)(4)(ii) refers to a "common owner of at least three percent" interest, Code § 414(m)(2)(B)(ii) was amended after the proposed regulations were issued to substitute "highly compensated employees (within the meaning of section 414(q))" for "officers, highly compensated employees, or owners."

With respect to B-Org affiliated service group test, even if the FSO is a corporation that is not a professional service corporation, it can still be an FSO.

Test B-Org in Both Directions

B-Org (or A-Org) affiliated service group status must be tested in both directions, looking at the possibility that the first entity is the FSO and the second entity is the B-Org, as well as the possibility that the first entity is the B-Org and the second entity is the FSO, because an entity that may not be an FSO may still be a B-Org and vice versa.

Examples of FSO and B-Org as Affiliated Service Group

The Proposed Treasury Regulations give the following as an example of a B-Organization. R is a service organization with 11 partners, each of whom owns 1% of the stock in Corporation D. Corporation D provides services to the partnership of a type historically performed by employees in the service field of the partnership. A significant portion of the business of the corporation consists of providing services to the partnership (i.e., the Total Receipts Percentage is 10% or more). If R is an FSO, Corporation D is a B-Org. because a significant portion of the business of D is the performance of services for the partnership of a type historically performed by employees in the service field of the partnership, and more than 10% of the interests in D are held, in the aggregate, by the designated group members (consisting of the 11 common owners of the partnership). If the ownership of the 11 partners in D stock was reduced to as little as 3% and at least 7% of D's stock was held by highly compensated employees of R who were not owners of R, the result would be the same. Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(c)(8), example (1).

Another example: Desert Horizon Financial Partners is a financial services partnership with 11 partners. Each partner of Desert Horizon owns one percent of the stock in Sagebrush Support Services, Inc. Sagebrush Support Services, Inc. provides services to the partnership of a type historically performed by employees in the financial services field. A significant portion of the business of Sagebrush Support Services consists of providing services to Desert Horizon Financial. Considering Desert Horizon Financial Partners as the FSO, Sagebrush Support Services, Inc. is a B-Org because: (i) a significant portion of its business is in the performance of services for the partnership of a type historically performed by employees in the financial services field; and (ii) more than 10% of the interests in the B-Org, Sagebrush Support Services, Inc., is held, in the aggregate, by the highly-compensated employees of the FSO (consisting of the 11 partners of Desert Horizon Financial Partners). Therefore, Sagebrush Support Services, Inc. (the B-Org) and Desert Horizon Financial Partners (the FSO) constitute an affiliated service group under Code § 414(m)(2)(B).

B-Org Flowchart

            The following flowchart illustrates the above B-Org affiliated service group rules.[9]

9. Management Organization Affiliated Service Groups Under Code § 414(m)(5)

            Management Organization Affiliated Service Group; Principal Business of One Organization to Perform Management Functions in Another Organizaiton. An affiliated service group also includes, under Code § 414(m)(5), a management organization affiliated service group, which is a group consisting of: (1) an organization the "principal business" of which is performing on a "regular and continuing basis" "management functions" for a recipient organization (or group of "related" recipient organizations as defined below);  and (2) such other organization.[10]

            1987 Proposed Regulations with Broad Interpretations of Management Activities; Withdrawn 1993. Proposed regulations on § 414(m)(5), proposed in Aug. 27, 1987, 52 Fed. Reg. 32502, but later withdrawn April 27, 1993, 58 Fed. Reg. 25587, provided that "principal business" means that more than 50% of the organization's gross receipts stem from the performance of management functions for the recipient organization. Withdrawn Proposed Regulation § l.414(m)-5(b).

            Management Activities as Detailed in 1987 Proposed Regulations. The proposed regulations on § 414(m)(5) that were later withdrawn defined "management functions" broadly to include management activities and services involving the determination, implementation or supervision of: (i) daily business operations (e.g., production, sales, marketing, purchasing and advertising), (ii) personnel (e.g., staffing, training, supervising, hiring and firing), (iii) employee compensation and benefits (e.g., salaries and wages, paid vacations and holidays, life and health insurance and pensions), (iv) short-range and long-range business planning (e.g., product development, budgeting, financing, expansion of operations, and capital investment), (v) organization structure and ownership (e.g., corporate formation, stock issues, dividends and mergers and acquisitions), and (vi) any other management activity or service. Management activities and services also include professional services that relate to these activities. Withdrawn Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-5(c)(1), proposed in Aug. 27, 1987, 52 Fed. Reg. 32502, but later withdrawn under President Clinton's Regulatory Burden Reduction Initiative April 27, 1993, 58 Fed. Reg. 25587.[11]

            Broad Definition of Organization. . For purposes of Code § 414(m)(5), an "organization" is defined in the most expansive sense to include a sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, trust, estate, or any other type of entity regardless of its ownership format. Withdrawn Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-5(a)(2); Joint Committee of Taxation General Explanation to TEFRA 1982. This ensures that the management organization rules apply even where an individual or unincorporated entity performs the management functions, preventing the use of specific legal structures to avoid aggregation.

            Historically Performed by Employees as Opposed to Outside Service Providers. The management functions must be of a type "historically performed by employees," a standard designed to distinguish between (i) core administrative services being "spun off" to avoid pension rules and (ii) legitimate third-party vendor relationships. Code § 414(m)(5); Withdrawn Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-5(c)(1). Under this test, a function is considered historically performed if it was not unusual for employees in that particular business field to perform such functions themselves, rather than hiring outside service providers, as of September 3, 1983. Withdrawn Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-5(c)(2). This benchmark is intended to protect traditional service provider relationships, such as those with independent accounting or payroll firms, that have historically operated as independent businesses.

            Principal Business, i.e., More than 50% of its Business Activities, on a Regular and Continuing Basis. An organization is typically considered a management organization if more than 50% of its business activities involve performing management functions and other services for a recipient organization. This determination is generally made using a two-tax-year rolling percentage based on gross receipts (or facts and circumstances if more appropriate). Withdrawn Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-5(b).[12]

            The Scope of Related Recipient Organizations. "Related organizations" is defined in Code § 414(m)(5) by reference to Code § 144(a)(3). Code § 144(a)(3) states that persons are related if (A) the relationship between such persons would result in a disallowance of losses under Code §§ 267 or 707(b), or (B) such persons are members of the same controlled group of corporations (as defined in Code § 1563(a), except that "more than 50%" is used instead of "at least 80%").[13] Under Code § 267(b), related persons include an individual and a corporation more than 50% owned by the individual, and a corporation and a partnership if the same person owns more than 50% of both the stock of the corporation and the capital or profits of the partnership, and certain similar relationships, and Code § 267(c) applies constructive ownership of stock rules. Code § 707(b) applies to a partnership and a greater than 50% owner of capital or profits therein, or to two partnerships where the same persons own more than 50% of capital or profits of each partnership. Therefore, if each recipient organizations is not related to each other, the principal business test of 414(m)(5) test is not me since there are not 50% or more of the receipts of the management organization are from the individual PA.

            1987 Proposed Regulations Often Looked to by Practitioners in Absence of Other Guidance Even Though Withdrawn. Although the reasons for the withdrawal were not stated, commentators have stated that the proposed regulations were thought to be too stringent an interpretation of the statute and met with considerable negative reaction. However, many practitioners do looked to these withdrawn proposed regulations for guidance because: (i)  these proposed regulations may provide some indication of the intentions of the IRS with respect to management organizations affiliated service groups; (ii) future guidance is not likely to be more onerous than the withdrawn proposed regulations, since these proposed regulations were thought to be too stringent; (iii) the proposed regulations were withdrawn under a broad regulatory burden reduction initiative, but not due to some inherent defect; and (iv) there is virtually no other guidance regarding these rules.

            IRS Examination Guidelines for Management Functions (Last Updated 2016). IRS Publication 7005 (Revised April 2016)—Employee Benefit Plans Explanation No. 10 Affiliated Service Group, www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p7005.pdf, which is a checklist to assist IRS agents in 5300 414(m) determination letter requests (which was available prior to 2017), provided regarding § 414(m)(5), that: (i) whether an organization's principal business is performing management functions on a regular and continuing basis for another organization is essentially a facts and circumstances question; (ii) factors to be considered could include the percentage of the organization's gross receipts that are derived from performing management functions for the other organization and the amount of time individuals actually spend performing these functions; (iii) a sufficient period of time (e.g., more than one year) must be considered to ensure that the "regular and continuing basis" condition is met; and (iv) the particular activities and services that the organization provides for the other organization must also be considered in order to determine that these activities and services are in the nature of management functions.

Examples of Management Organization Affiliated Service Group

            Example 1: The Two-Tax-Year Rolling Test. In 2025, Management Co. derives 40% of its gross receipts from management services for Recipient Inc. In 2026, that figure rises to 65%. For the 2026 plan year, Management Co. satisfies the "principal business" test because its average gross receipts from the recipient over the two-tax-year period (2025 and 2026) exceed 50%. Consequently, Management Co. and Recipient Inc. are treated as a single employer for the 2026 plan year, even though the threshold wasn't met in the first year alone.  

            Example 2: Aggregation of Related Recipients. A manager provides services to three separate companies: Company A, Company B, and Company C. The manager derives 20% of its income from each company (60% total). If the three companies are unrelated, the manager does not meet the 50% principal business test for any single recipient. However, if Companies A, B, and C are part of a controlled group under Code § 414(b), they are treated as a single "recipient group." In this case, the manager’s 60% total receipts exceed the 50% threshold, and the manager is aggregated with all three companies.           

            Example 3: Professional Services as Management Functions. A group of doctors forms a separate Billing and Professional Support entity. The support entity provides billing services and also employs several physicians who perform medical services for the primary clinic. Because the support entity is performing the same type of professional services (medical care) that the clinic provides to the public, those professional services are automatically treated as "management functions."  These receipts are added to the billing service receipts to determine if the support entity meets the 50% principal business test.

            Example 4: Aggregation of Aggregated Groups. Geneva BioPharma Corp. and Aris Therapeutics constitute a controlled group of entities under Code § 414(b). Nexus Services and Horizon Management Group constitute an affiliated service group under Code § 414(m)(2). Assume Nexus Services or Horizon Management Group (or both) perform management functions and other services for Geneva BioPharma Corp. or Aris Therapeutics (or both), and the performance of these management functions or services satisfies the requirements of a principal business on a regular and continuing basis. Nexus Services and Horizon Management Group are treated as a single management organization, and Geneva BioPharma Corp. and Aris Therapeutics are treated as a single recipient organization for purposes of Code § 414(m)(5). Geneva BioPharma Corp., Aris Therapeutics, Nexus Services, and Horizon Management Group would constitute an affiliated service group under Code § 414(m)(5).

10. Conclusion

            Practitioners must diligently analyze the relationships between entities whose principal business is the performance of services or management to determine if an affiliated service group exists, and the ramifications of such a finding. The affiliated service group rules are complex, and each case must be analyzed carefully.




[1] Note that Code § 269A which, if applicable, permits a reallocation of income, credits, exclusions, etc., between the personal service corporation and its employer owners. However, IRS Private Letter Ruling 8737001 (April 13, 1987) held that a sole shareholder professional corporation which was in a medical partnership was not formed or availed of for the principal purpose of avoiding federal income within the meaning of Code § 269A.

[2] Code § 414(m)(2)(B) would not encompass legitimately classified independent contractors.

[3] The same rule was provided in regulations proposed in 1987 under § 414(m)(5) but the § 414(m)(5) proposed regulations were withdrawn in 1993.

[4] Prop. Treas. Reg. § 1.414(m)-2(d) referred to the constructive ownership rules of Code § 267(c). However, these proposed regulations were issued before the constructive ownership reference in Code § 414(m)(6)((B) was changed by the Deficit Reduction Act Of 1984 from § 267(c) to § 318(a).

[5] See, e.g., Strauss and Shaw, Regs. Leave Questions on Affiliated-Service Groups, 53 Tax'n for Acct. 92 (Aug. 1994).

[6] See Danziger, Controlled Groups, Affiliated Service Groups, Leased Employees and Other Aggregation Rules Under Code Subsections 414(b), (C), (m), (n) and (0), C759 ALI-ABA 105 (1992) that notes that the proposed regulations give little guidance as to what regularly performing services for or regularly associated with means. It poses the query as to what if two entities render no services to each other and their relationship is limited to routine referrals, does this referral relationship constitute regularly associated with providing services to third parties. It notes that one should consider the facts and circumstances.

[7] Note that while the § 414(m) regulations proposed in 1983 have never been finalized, various provisions of the proposed § 414(m) regulations have been cited in IRS private letter rulings and in the Internal Revenue Manual. Furthermore, Prop. Treas. Reg. § 414(m)-1(c) regarding a non-PC corporation not being an FSO for A-Org. affiliated service group purposes is specifically cited in IRS Publication 7005 (Revised June 2011) — Employee Benefit Plans Explanation No. 10 Affiliated Service Group.

[8] Code § 414(m)(2)(B) would not encompass independent contractors.

[9]  These A-Org and B-Org flowcharts are from IRS Employee Plans Continuing Professional Education materials (Controlled and Affiliated Service Groups) (2004).

[10] See, e.g., Grande v. Grant Thornton LLP, 2013 WL 5450379 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2013) (court examined whether Grant Thornton and its related entities could be treated as a single employer for retirement plan purposes under Code §§ 414(b), (c), and (m); court notes that even without common ownership, the high degree of functional integration and shared management services between a professional firm and its regional or service-specific entities can trigger aggregation under the affiliated service group of Code § 414(m)(5), if principal business of one entity is to perform management functions for the other entity on a regular and continuing basis); Rogers v. I D Design, Inc., 2009 WL 10668634 (N.D. Ga. Mar. 6, 2009) (holding that several related furniture retail and wholesale entities were not an affiliated service group under Code § 414(m)(5) because, despite shared ownership and shared administrative / accounting personnel, the plaintiffs failed to produce evidence that the "principal business" of any one entity was the performance of management functions for the others; consequently, the entities were not aggregated, and the employer remained exempt from COBRA under the small business exception); Beals Bros. Management Corp. v. C.I.R., 300 F.3d 963 (8th Cir. 2002) (Code § 414(m)(5) used to aggregate a management corporation with an operating sawmill company; because the management entity’s primary business was performing oversight for the sawmill, they formed an affiliated service group; this required the management entity's ESOP to satisfy nondiscrimination testing against the combined workforce of both companies, a standard it could not meet because it excluded all non-highly compensated sawmill employees).

[11] Management activities also include professional services that relate to these management functions. Id. Furthermore, if an organization performs the same type of professional services for a recipient that the recipient provides to third parties, those services are deemed management functions regardless of whether they were historically performed by employees. Id.

[12] See, IRS Field Service Advice TL-N-6910-95, 1995 WL 1918546 (a management organization can be aggregated with a specific recipient even if it serves multiple unrelated clients, provided the "principal business" test is met for that particular recipient or related group; performing services for organizations that are not part of an affiliated service group does not prevent the formation of an affiliated service group with another organization that meets the 50% of business activities requirement); Field Service Advice TL-N-6910-95, 1995 WL 1918536 (deriving more than 50% of gross receipts from a single recipient is a primary factor in identifying a management organization; however, this is a facts-and-circumstances test and other factors include the amount billed and the actual time individuals spend performing management functions; at a minimum, management functions must be performed for at least two years to satisfy regular and continuing; even if organizations are related, if the management functions performed for a specific related entity are de minimis, e.g., only 2% of gross receipts, that specific entity might be excluded from the aggregated ASG group).

[13] Code § 267(b) defines related person as including: (i) members of the same family, (ii) an individual and a corporation more than 50% owned by the individual, and (iii) a corporation and a partnership if the same persons more than 50% of both the stock of the corporation and the capital or profits of the partnership, and certain similar relationships, and Code § 267(c) applies constructive ownership of stock rules. Code § 707(b) applies to a partnership and a greater than 50% owner of capital or profits therein, or to two partnerships where the same persons own more than 50% of capital or profits of each partnership. Code § 1563(a) is very similar to Code § 414(b) discussed above.

 

Sunday, June 1, 2025

Right to a Jury Trial in ERISA Cases


Right to a Jury Trial in ERISA Cases

Charles C. Shulman, Esq.
cshulman@ebeclaw.com
201.357.0577

June, 2025

See link below to article.

There is a recent trend in some federal cases to allow requests for jury trials for ERISA claims, such as claims for benefits or breach of fiduciary duty claims, even though historically such claims were treated as equitable claims, not entitled to a jury trial. Three district cases allowing jury trials are in the Second Circuit and relate to excessive fee cases.  Jury trial verdicts are unpredictable, particularly in complex ERISA fiduciary cases.  In light of the possibility of a jury trial in excessive fee cases, increased emphasis and care should be taken in the selection and overseeing of service providers, bids from multiple recordkeepers should be compared and 401(k) plan investment funds should be selected and monitored based on advice of independent financial advisors.

1.    Right to Jury Trial in ERISA Legal Claims

ERISA does not explicitly address a plaintiff’s right to a jury trial, and its legislative history provides no clarification. Federal courts have looked to the Seventh Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which guarantees the right to a jury trial in federal common law cases, but not in equitable cases. Historically, most ERISA claims have been viewed as equitable or partially equitable and not entitled to a jury trial. However, some recent cases granted jury trial requests for ERISA claims that seek benefits under the plan or seek to make the plan whole for monetary losses due to fiduciary breaches.

 

2.    Jury Trials in Legal but Not Equitable Claims

Federal Caselaw Holds that the Right to a Jury Trial is for Legal but Not Equitable Claims. The Supreme Court has addressed the issue of the right to a jury trial for legal but not equitable claims on a number of occasions. For example, in the recent case of Securities and Exchange Commission v. Jarkesy, 603 U.S. 109 (2024), the Court held that that the SEC's pursuit of civil penalties in securities fraud cases even within an administrative setting, was still considered a legal claim, not an equitable claim, and therefore the defendants could assert their right to a jury trial.  

Two-Part Test to Determine if Right to Jury Trial Exists. To determine whether a particular action will resolve legal rights or equitable rights, courts examine both the nature of the issues involved and the remedy sought. See, e.g., Granfinanciera, S.A. v. Nordberg, 492 U.S. 33, 42 (1989), holding that Granfinanciera, S.A. had the right to a jury trial when sued by the trustee in bankruptcy to recover allegedly fraudulent monetary transfer, stated that there are two tests to determine if a jury trial is allowed: (i) the court compares the statutory action to 18th-century actions brought in the courts of England prior to the merger of the courts of law and equity; and (ii) the court examines the remedy sought and determine whether it is legal or equitable in nature.  The Court noted here and in other cases that the second test is more important than the first.

3.    Jury Trial for ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) Denial of Benefits Claims

Cases Denying Jury Trial for ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) Claims for Benefits under the Plan. Most cases have denied jury trials for an ERISA denial of benefits claim under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), viewing such claims as equitable, similar to enforcing a trust. Under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), a civil action may be brought by a participant or beneficiary to recover benefits due under the terms of his plan, to enforce his or her rights under the terms of the plan, or to clarify his or her rights to future benefits under the terms of the plan. For examples of cases that have denied jury trials in § 502(a)(1)(B) denial of benefits claims because they involve primarily equitable claims, see, e.g., Kramer v. American Electric Power Executive Severance Plan, 128 F.4th 739 (6th Cir. 2025) (employee brought action under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) for denial of severance benefits under executive severance plan and interference under ERISA; plaintiff asserted constitutional right to a jury trial for ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) denial of benefits claim; court held that ERISA claim for denial-of-benefits is equitable in nature; thus, plaintiff was not entitled to a jury trial on ERISA claim for benefits); Graham v. Hartford Life & Accident Ins. Co., 589 F.3d 1345 (10th Cir. 2009) (the Seventh Amendment guarantees no right to a jury trial in an ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) action for benefits because the relief is equitable rather than legal); Wilkins v. Baptist Healthcare Sys. Inc., 150 F.3d 609, 616 (6th Cir. 1998) (former employee brought ERISA claim against employer and benefit plan administrator, alleging that the administrator's denial of disability benefits violated ERISA; court held that a claim for denial of benefits was not a case for money damages and therefore plaintiff was not entitled to a jury trial); Biggers v. Wittek Industries, Inc., 4 F.3d 291 (4th Cir. 1993) (claim for benefits under an ERISA welfare plan was covered by ERISA, and because ERISA preempts his common law contract claim, the claim should have been tried by the court under the principles of ERISA); Bair v. General Motors Corp., 895 F.2d 1094 (6th Cir. 1990) (former employee sued former employer under ERISA, seeking special early retirement benefit; court rejected appellant's argument that he was entitled to a jury merely because issues of contract law are involved in his claim).

Some Cases Allowing Jury Trials for ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B) Denial of Benefits Claims. Some cases have held that jury trial requests were allowed even in claims for benefits under ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), as they were held to involve legal claims, like claims for damages. See, e.g., Cox v. Keystone Carbon Co., 861 F.2d 390 (3d Cir.1988) (court acknowledged the difference between the relief provided ERISA § 502(a)(1)(B), which is “legal,” and the relief provided ERISA § 502(a)(3)(A) & (B), which is “equitable,” citing Tull v. United States, 481 U.S. 412 (1987); remanded to district court to determine whether the § 502(a)(1)(B) claim was presented to it and if so, whether he was entitled to a jury trial thereunder); Rhodes v. Piggly Wiggly Alabama Distributing Co., Inc., 741 F. Supp. 1542 (N.D. Ala. 1990) (an action under ERISA § 502(a)(1) is legal in nature and there is a Seventh Amendment right to jury trial).

4.    Fiduciary Breach Claims under ERISA § 502(a)(2) are Held by Most Courts to be Equitable Claims Not Entitled to a Jury Trial

With regard to ERISA fiduciary claims under ERISA § 502(a)(2) to remedy fiduciary breaches under ERISA § 409(a), most courts have held that ERISA fiduciary claims are equitable in nature and are not entitled to a jury trial. See, e.g., Acument Global Technologies, Inc.. v. Towers Watson & Co., 998 F. Supp. 2d 111 (S.D.N.Y. 2014) (rejecting jury demand in ERISA fiduciary breach case because the remedy sought was the classic remedy against a fiduciary, namely, a surcharge to repair the damage his breach of duty inflicted upon the corpus that the fiduciary was charged to protect, which is an equitable claim); Bauer-Ramazani v. Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America-College Retirement and Equities Fund, No. 1:09–CV–190, 2013 WL 6189802 (D. Vermont 2013) (granting motion to strike jury demand in ERISA claim for breach of fiduciary duty, because the remedy plaintiffs seek under ERISA, the value of the use of the plan assets and disgorgement of any investment profits made through the use of plaintiffs’ funds, are equitable in nature); Carver v. Bank of New York Mellon, No. 15-CV-10180, 2017 WL 1208598 (S.D.N.Y. 2017) (court concludes that the remedy sought by plaintiffs for defendants' alleged breach of fiduciary duty is equitable in nature; defendants' motion to strike plaintiffs' demand for a jury trial was therefore granted); Divane v. Northwestern University, 953 F.3d 980 (7th Cir. 2020), vacated on other grounds, 142 S. Ct. 737 (2022) (court stated there would be no right to jury trial for fiduciary claim); In Re First American Corp. ERISA Litigation, No. SACV 07-01357-JVS, 2009 WL 536254 (C.D. Cal. 2009) (overwhelming weight of authority in the federal courts holds that actions under ERISA § 502(a)(2) by participant, beneficiaries or fiduciaries to remedy alleged fiduciary violations of ERISA § 409(a) are equitable in nature and have no 7th Amendment jury trial right); Harmon v. Shell Oil Co., No. 3:20-cv-00021, 2023 WL 2474503 (S.D. Tex. Mar. 13, 2023) (given the equitable nature of the claims and relief that plaintiffs seek, court denied jury request); Popovchak v. UnitedHealth Group Inc., 692 F.Supp.3d 392, (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 19, 2023)  (suit against claims administrators alleging failure to adequately reimburse beneficiaries for medical services in violation of plan and their fiduciary duties; court held beneficiaries adequately alleged that claims administrators breached their fiduciary duty of loyalty; beneficiaries adequately alleged losses resulting from administrators' alleged conduct; and beneficiaries did not have Seventh Amendment right to jury trial with regard to breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims, because it was not clear whether plaintiffs sought legal damages for their fiduciary duty claims, and the Second Circuit has long held that ERISA benefits claims do not trigger the right to a jury trial, the court grants defendants’ motion to strike plaintiffs’ jury demand without prejudice).

5.    Several Recent District Court Cases in the Second Circuit Have Allowed Jury Trials even for Fiduciary Breach Claims under ERISA § 502(a)(2)

Three recent district court decisions in the Second Circuit have granted jury trials in ERISA fiduciary breach cases.

a.    Jury Trial Allowed in Garthwait v. Eversource Energy Service Company (D. Conn.) and rather than go to Jury Trial, Defendants Settled for $15 Million.  In Garthwait v. Eversource Energy Service Company, No. 3:20-CV-00902, 2022 WL 17484817 (JCH) (D. Conn. Dec. 7, 2022), the court allowed a jury trial for the plaintiffs' claim for Eversource to restore (“make good”) any losses caused by breaches of fiduciary duty related to the company's 401(k) plan. In that case, participants in the 401(k) plan alleged breach of fiduciary duty by allowing underperforming investments in the 401(k) plan's choice of funds. The court held that the make-good claim was a legal remedy rather than an equitable remedy because it sought monetary damages to compensate for the losses caused by the alleged breaches, and therefore plaintiffs request for a jury trial with respect to the make-good claims was valid.  The case was subsequently prepared for a jury trial scheduled for April 2023, but as a result of the risks of a jury trial the parties reached a $15 million settlement in September, 2023.

b.    Jury Trial Allowed in Vellali v. Yale University (D. Conn.) but Jury Acquitted on Basis of “Could Have” Standard; Plaintiffs Appealing to Second Circuit. In Vellali v. Yale University, 662 F.Supp.3d 238 (D. Conn. Mar. 17, 2023), a class of participants in Yale University's 403(b) Retirement Account Plan brought suit under ERISA § 502(a)(2) against the plan fiduciaries for breach of fiduciary duties and other ERISA claims in connection with alleged excessive recordkeeping and administrative fees, noting that the plan used multiple recordkeepers, and selected an imprudent choice of investment funds. The plaintiffs made a jury request. The district court stated that the remedy is legal in nature since they seek to recover damages out of the defendant's assets rather than to recover specifically identifiable funds, and the court therefore held that the plaintiffs have the right to a jury trial in this case on their claims for money damages.

       The jury in the Vellali v. Yale University case found in June 2023 that Yale University fiduciaries had breached their fiduciary duty of prudence by allowing unreasonable recordkeeping and administrative fees, but that the plaintiffs didn't prove any resulting damages since Yale University demonstrated that a prudent fiduciary "could have" made the same decisions as to recordkeeping and administrative fees. The jury also sided with Yale University on the appropriateness of investment monitoring and share class selection. The plaintiffs appealed to the Second Circuit claiming that the jury instructions in the trial did not adequately guide the jury on how to assess damages, specifically regarding the "could have" versus "would have" standard for determining if a prudent fiduciary would have made the same decisions as the defendants. The appeal is pending.

c.    Jury Trial Allowed in Khan v. Board of Directors of Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan (S.D.N.Y.) and Jury Awarded $38 million for Unreasonable Recordkeeping and Administrative Fees. In Khan v. Board of Directors of Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan, No. 20-CV-07561, 2023 WL 6237862 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 26, 2023), participants in the Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan for Financial Institutions (a pooled 401(k) plan) brought suit under ERISA § 502(a)(2) alleging that plan fiduciaries at Pentegra and the Board breached their ERISA fiduciary duties by allowing unreasonable recordkeeping and administrative fees. The plaintiffs amended their claim to request a jury trial. The Southern District of New York in the 2023 case found that the ERISA § 502(a)(2) claim against the fiduciaries involves legal and equitable claims, and therefore held that the case should be bifurcated with the claim for money damages being tried before a jury, and the remaining equitable claims and prohibited transaction claims should be tried before the court.

       On April 23, 2025, a jury in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York rendered a unanimous verdict in Khan v. Board of Directors of Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan, that the defendants breached their fiduciary duties under ERISA in connection with administration and fees charged for participation in the Pentegra pooled 401(k) plan, and as a result, the jury awarded the plaintiffs damages exceeding $38 million. A court decision regarding the equitable and prohibited transaction claims had not yet been issued, and according to a May 2, 2025 S.D.N.Y. court order, the parties in Khan v. Board of Directors of Pentegra Defined Contribution Plan, have reached a settlement in principle for the remaining claims.

6.    Points to Consider in Light of Possibility of Jury Trials for Excessive Fee Cases

●    The intricacies of ERISA excessive fee cases make jury trials particularly unpredictable.

●    In light of the possibility of a jury trial in excessive fee cases, increased emphasis and care should be taken in the selection and overseeing of service providers and in reviewing the fee structures from time to time.

●    RFPs from multiple recordkeepers should be compared.

●    401(k) plan investment funds should be selected and monitored based on advice of independent financial advisors, and the funds’ returns and risks should be benchmarked.

●    Recordkeepers with a relationship with the plan sponsor should be avoided.

●    It should be interesting to see if this trend to allow jury trials in ERISA fiduciary excessive fee cases spreads beyond the Second Circuit.

Also Published in Journal of Pension Planning & Compliance (WK, Winter 2026) 

at https://drive.google.com/file/d/11PU_wpBJNl-PZmAMO3bfVLphahKqzMlI/


2027 Cost of Living Adjustments for Retirement and Benefit Plans

  2027 BENEFIT PLAN COST-OF-LIVING ADJUSTMENTS *   Charles C. Shulman, Esq. 201-357-0577 212-380-3834 cshulman@ebeclaw.com The chart b...